For whales and seals the ocean is not blue: a visual pigment loss in marine mammals*
: Dr Leo Peichl, as above. E‐mail: peichl@mpih‐frankfurt.mpg.de
*This paper is dedicated to the late Professor Brian B. Boycott FRS (1924–2000), great scientist, teacher and friend.
Abstract
Most terrestrial mammals have colour vision based on two spectrally different visual pigments located in two types of retinal cone photoreceptors, i.e. they are cone dichromats with long‐to‐middle‐wave‐sensitive (commonly green) L‐cones and short‐wave‐sensitive (commonly blue) S‐cones. With visual pigment‐specific antibodies, we here demonstrate an absence of S‐cones in the retinae of all whales and seals studied. The sample includes seven species of toothed whales (Odontoceti) and five species of marine carnivores (eared and earless seals). These marine mammals have only L‐cones (cone monochromacy) and hence are essentially colour‐blind. For comparison, the study also includes the wolf, ferret and European river otter (Carnivora) as well as the mouflon and pygmy hippopotamus (Artiodactyla), close terrestrial relatives of the seals and whales, respectively. These have a normal complement of S‐cones and L‐cones. The S‐cone loss in marine species from two distant mammalian orders strongly argues for convergent evolution and an adaptive advantage of that trait in the marine visual environment. To us this suggests that the S‐cones may have been lost in all whales and seals. However, as the spectral composition of light in clear ocean waters is increasingly blue‐shifted with depth, an S‐cone loss would seem particularly disadvantageous. We discuss some hypotheses to explain this paradox.
Citing Literature
Number of times cited: 81
- Alla M. Mass and Alexander Y. Supin, Vision, Encyclopedia of Marine Mammals, 10.1016/B978-0-12-804327-1.00266-1, (1035-1044), (2018).
- Shaun P Collin, Scene through the eyes of an apex predator: a comparative analysis of the shark visual system, Clinical and Experimental Optometry, 101, 5, (624-640), (2018).
- Emily C. Turner, Eva K. Sawyer and Jon H. Kaas, Optic nerve, superior colliculus, visual thalamus, and primary visual cortex of the northern elephant seal (Mirounga angustirostris) and California sea lion (Zalophus californianus), Journal of Comparative Neurology, 525, 9, (2109-2132), (2017).
- Thomas W. Cronin, Jeffry I. Fasick, Lorian E. Schweikert, Sönke Johnsen, Lorren J. Kezmoh and Mark F. Baumgartner, Coping with copepods: do right whales (Eubalaena glacialis) forage visually in dark waters?, Philosophical Transactions of the Royal Society B: Biological Sciences, 372, 1717, (20160067), (2017).
- Livia S. Carvalho, Daniel M. A. Pessoa, Jessica K. Mountford, Wayne I. L. Davies and David M. Hunt, The Genetic and Evolutionary Drives behind Primate Color Vision, Frontiers in Ecology and Evolution, 5, (2017).
- Gaëtan Richard, Olga A. Filatova, Filipa I. P. Samarra, Ivan D. Fedutin, Marc Lammers and Patrick J. Miller, Icelandic herring-eating killer whales feed at night, Marine Biology, 164, 2, (2017).
- Bruno Cozzi, Stefan Huggenberger and Helmut Oelschläger, Head and Senses, Anatomy of Dolphins, 10.1016/B978-0-12-407229-9.00005-1, (133-196), (2017).
- Peter Simard, Cetacean Sensory Systems, Encyclopedia of Animal Cognition and Behavior, 10.1007/978-3-319-47829-6_939-1, (1-9), (2017).
- Heidrun Kuhrt, Andreas Bringmann, Wolfgang Härtig, Gudrun Wibbelt, Leo Peichl and Andreas Reichenbach, The Retina of Asian and African Elephants: Comparison of Newborn and Adult, Brain, Behavior and Evolution, 10.1159/000464097, 89, 2, (84-103), (2017).
- Lorian E. Schweikert, Jeffry I. Fasick and Michael S. Grace, Evolutionary loss of cone photoreception in balaenid whales reveals circuit stability in the mammalian retina, Journal of Comparative Neurology, 524, 14, (2873-2885), (2016).
- Hrvoje Smodlaka, Wael A. Khamas, Lauren Palmer, Bryan Lui, Josip A. Borovac, Brian A. Cohn and Lars Schmitz, Eye Histology and Ganglion Cell Topography of Northern Elephant Seals (irounga angustirostris), The Anatomical Record, 299, 6, (798-805), (2016).
- Mark S. Springer, Christopher A. Emerling, Noah Fugate, Rachna Patel, James Starrett, Phillip A. Morin, Cheryl Hayashi and John Gatesy, Inactivation of Cone-Specific Phototransduction Genes in Rod Monochromatic Cetaceans, Frontiers in Ecology and Evolution, 4, (2016).
- Jeffry I. Fasick and Phyllis R. Robinson, Adaptations of Cetacean Retinal Pigments to Aquatic Environments, Frontiers in Ecology and Evolution, 4, (2016).
- R. H. Douglas and T. W. Cronin, Visual Matched Filtering in Vertebrates, The Ecology of Animal Senses, 10.1007/978-3-319-25492-0_7, (169-203), (2015).
- Daniela Oppermann, Jürgen Schramme and Christa Neumeyer, Rod-cone based color vision in seals under photopic conditions, Vision Research, 125, (30), (2016).
- Carmen M. H. Colitz, Michael T. Walsh and Stephen D. McCulloch, CHARACTERIZATION OF ANTERIOR SEGMENT OPHTHALMOLOGIC LESIONS IDENTIFIED IN FREE-RANGING DOLPHINS AND THOSE UNDER HUMAN CARE, Journal of Zoo and Wildlife Medicine, 47, 1, (56), (2016).
- Dorothee Kremers, Aurélie Célérier, Benoist Schaal, Sylvie Campagna, Marie Trabalon, Martin Böye, Martine Hausberger and Alban Lemasson, Sensory Perception in Cetaceans: Part I—Current Knowledge about Dolphin Senses As a Representative Species, Frontiers in Ecology and Evolution, 4, (2016).
- Nathan S. HART and Shaun P. COLLIN, Sharks senses and shark repellents, Integrative Zoology, 10, 1, (38-64), (2015).
- Annalisa Berta, James L. Sumich and Kit M. Kovacs, Integumentary and Sensory Systems, Marine Mammals, 10.1016/B978-0-12-397002-2.00007-7, (169-210), (2015).
- Shaun P. Collin, Ryan M. Kempster and Kara E. Yopak, How Elasmobranchs Sense Their Environment, Physiology of Elasmobranch Fishes: Structure and Interaction with Environment, 10.1016/B978-0-12-801289-5.00002-X, (19-99), (2015).
- Lukas Hofmann and Krzysztof Palczewski, Advances in understanding the molecular basis of the first steps in color vision, Progress in Retinal and Eye Research, 49, (46), (2015).
- Christopher A. Emerling, Hieu T. Huynh, Minh A. Nguyen, Robert W. Meredith and Mark S. Springer, Spectral shifts of mammalian ultraviolet-sensitive pigments (short wavelength-sensitive opsin 1) are associated with eye length and photic niche evolution, Proceedings of the Royal Society B: Biological Sciences, 282, 1819, (20151817), (2015).
- V. Schluessel, I. P. Rick and K. Plischke, No rainbow for grey bamboo sharks: evidence for the absence of colour vision in sharks from behavioural discrimination experiments, Journal of Comparative Physiology A, 10.1007/s00359-014-0940-0, 200, 11, (939-947), (2014).
- Joseph T. Svoke, Rebecca J. Snyder and Jenny Brink Elgart, Preliminary evidence for color stimuli discrimination in the Asian small-clawed otter (Aonyx cinerea), Learning & Behavior, 42, 2, (176), (2014).
- DAVID M. HUNT and LEO PEICHL, S cones: Evolution, retinal distribution, development, and spectral sensitivity, Visual Neuroscience, 10.1017/S0952523813000242, 31, 02, (115-138), (2013).
- Kate D. L. Umbers, On the perception, production and function of blue colouration in animals, Journal of Zoology, 289, 4, (229-242), (2012).
- C. Scholtyssek and G. Dehnhardt, Brightness discrimination in the South African fur seal (Arctocephalus pusillus), Vision Research, 84, (26), (2013).
- Kerstin Fritsches and Eric Warrant, Vision, The Biology of Sea Turtles, Volume III, 10.1201/b13895-3, (31-58), (2013).
- Camilah Antunes Zappes, Camila Ventura da Silva, Mônica Pontalti, Mônica Lauriano Danielski and Ana Paula Madeira Di Beneditto, The conflict between the southern right whale and coastal fisheries on the southern coast of Brazil, Marine Policy, 38, (428), (2013).
- Sarah Miller, Don Samuelson and Richard Dubielzig, Anatomic features of the cetacean globe, Veterinary Ophthalmology, 16, (52-63), (2013).
- GERALD H. JACOBS, Losses of functional opsin genes, short-wavelength cone photopigments, and color vision—A significant trend in the evolution of mammalian vision, Visual Neuroscience, 30, 1-2, (39), (2013).
- Carrie C. Veilleux, Edward E. Louis and Deborah A. Bolnick, Nocturnal Light Environments Influence Color Vision and Signatures of Selection on the OPN1SW Opsin Gene in Nocturnal Lemurs, Molecular Biology and Evolution, 30, 6, (1420), (2013).
- Ewa Krzyszczyk and Janet Mann, Why become speckled? Ontogeny and function of speckling in Shark Bay bottlenose dolphins (Tursiops sp.)1, Marine Mammal Science, 28, 2, (295), (2012).
- Michael J. Pauers, James A. Kuchenbecker, Maureen Neitz and Jay Neitz, Changes in the colour of light cue circadian activity, Animal Behaviour, 10.1016/j.anbehav.2012.01.035, 83, 5, (1143-1151), (2012).
- Ferenc I. Hárosi and Iñigo Novales Flamarique, Functional significance of the taper of vertebrate cone photoreceptors, The Journal of General Physiology, 10.1085/jgp.201110692, 139, 2, (159-187), (2012).
- Brian W. Kot, Richard Sears, Ayal Anis, Douglas P. Nowacek, Jason Gedamke and Christopher D. Marshall, Behavioral responses of minke whales (Balaenoptera acutorostrata) to experimental fishing gear in a coastal environment, Journal of Experimental Marine Biology and Ecology, 413, (13), (2012).
- Jeffry I. Fasick, Nicole Bischoff, Stephanie Brennan, Stephani Velasquez and Gisele Andrade, Estimated absorbance spectra of the visual pigments of the North Atlantic right whale (Eubalaena glacialis), Marine Mammal Science, 27, 4, (E321-E331), (2011).
- Peter Skorupski and Lars Chittka, Is colour cognitive?, Optics & Laser Technology, 43, 2, (251), (2011).
- Eduardo de A. Gutierrez, Beatriz M. Pegoraro, Bráulio Magalhães-Castro and Valdir F. Pessoa, Behavioural evidence of dichromacy in a species of South American marsupial, Animal Behaviour, 81, 5, (1049), (2011).
- Nathan Scott Hart, Susan Michelle Theiss, Blake Kristin Harahush and Shaun Patrick Collin, Microspectrophotometric evidence for cone monochromacy in sharks, Naturwissenschaften, 98, 3, (193), (2011).
- Sarah N. Miller, Carmen M. H. Colitz and Richard R. Dubielzig, Anatomy of the California sea lion globe, Veterinary Ophthalmology, 13, (63-71), (2010).
- Gerald H. Jacobs, The Verriest Lecture 2009: Recent progress in understanding mammalian color vision, Ophthalmic and Physiological Optics, 30, 5, (422-434), (2010).
- Wiebke Ebeling, Riccardo C. Natoli, Jan M. Hemmi and Eric Warrant, Diversity of Color Vision: Not All Australian Marsupials Are Trichromatic, PLoS ONE, 5, 12, (e14231), (2010).
- Tomoko Koito, Kaoru Kubokawa, Shinsuke Tanabe and Nobuyuki Miyazaki, Phylogenetic analyses in cetacean species of the family Delphinidae using a short wavelength sensitive opsin gene sequence, Fisheries Science, 76, 4, (571), (2010).
- TADAMICHI MORISAKA, Overview of comparative cognitive studies of dolphins in Japan, Japanese Psychological Research, 51, 3, (168-176), (2009).
- Frederike Diana Hanke and Guido Dehnhardt, Aerial visual acuity in harbor seals (Phoca vitulina) as a function of luminance, Journal of Comparative Physiology A, 195, 7, (643), (2009).
- Frederike D. Hanke, Wolf Hanke, Christine Scholtyssek and Guido Dehnhardt, Basic mechanisms in pinniped vision, Experimental Brain Research, 199, 3-4, (299), (2009).
- Alla M. Mass and Alexander Ya. Supin, Vision, Encyclopedia of Marine Mammals, 10.1016/B978-0-12-373553-9.00275-3, (1200-1211), (2009).
- T.W. Cronin, Visual Ecology, The Senses: A Comprehensive Reference, 10.1016/B978-012370880-9.00337-6, (211-245), (2008).
- Susan G. Heaslip and Sascha K. Hooker, Effect of animal-borne camera and flash on the diving behaviour of the female Antarctic fur seal (Arctocephalus gazella), Deep Sea Research Part I: Oceanographic Research Papers, 55, 9, (1179), (2008).
- Christine Scholtyssek, Almut Kelber and Guido Dehnhardt, Brightness discrimination in the harbor seal (Phoca vitulina), Vision Research, 48, 1, (96), (2008).
- James K. Bowmaker, Evolution of vertebrate visual pigments, Vision Research, 48, 20, (2022), (2008).
- Ellen J. Gerl and Molly R. Morris, The Causes and Consequences of Color Vision, Evolution: Education and Outreach, 1, 4, (476), (2008).
- J. Carroll and G.H. Jacobs, Mammalian Photopigments, The Senses: A Comprehensive Reference, 10.1016/B978-012370880-9.00257-7, (247-268), (2008).
- K. Newman and A. M. Springer, Nocturnal activity by mammal‐eating killer whales at a predation hot spot in the Bering Sea, Marine Mammal Science, 24, 4, (990-999), (2008).
- Alla M. Mass and Alexander YA. Supin, Adaptive features of aquatic mammals' eye, The Anatomical Record, 290, 6, (701-715), (2007).
- Ulrike Griebel, Gertrude KÖnig and Axel Schmid, SPECTRAL SENSITIVITY IN TWO SPECIES OF PINNIPEDS (PHOCA VITULINA AND OTARIA FLAVESCENS), Marine Mammal Science, 22, 1, (156-166), (2006).
- David H. Levenson, Paul J. Ponganis, Michael A. Crognale, Jess F. Deegan, Andy Dizon and Gerald H. Jacobs, Visual pigments of marine carnivores: pinnipeds, polar bear, and sea otter, Journal of Comparative Physiology A, 192, 8, (833), (2006).
- Frederike D. Hanke, Guido Dehnhardt, Frank Schaeffel and Wolf Hanke, Corneal topography, refractive state, and accommodation in harbor seals (Phoca vitulina), Vision Research, 46, 6-7, (837), (2006).
- Annalisa Berta, James L. Sumich, Kit M. Kovacs, Pieter Arend Folkens and Peter J. Adam, Integumentary and Sensory Systems, Marine Mammals, 10.1016/B978-012088552-7/50008-4, (132-II), (2006).
- Michael Weiffen, Bettina Möller, Björn Mauck and Guido Dehnhardt, Effect of water turbidity on the visual acuity of harbor seals (Phoca vitulina), Vision Research, 46, 11, (1777), (2006).
- Leo Peichl, Diversity of mammalian photoreceptor properties: Adaptations to habitat and lifestyle?, "The Anatomical Record Part A: Discoveries in Molecular, Cellular, and Evolutionary Biology", 287A, 1, (1001-1012), (2005).
- LUCY A. NEWMAN and PHYLLIS R. ROBINSON, Cone visual pigments of aquatic mammals, Visual Neuroscience, 22, 06, (873), (2005).
- ATSUKO KON-NO, KIYOSHI ASAHINA, CHIHIRO YUMIOKA, HIROSHI KOBAYASHI, TSUNEO ARAHATA and TSUKASA MURAYAMA, Discrimination of achromatic colors in a bottlenose dolphin, Japanese Journal of Animal Psychology, 55, 2, (59), (2005).
- Gary A. Williams, Jack B. Calderone and Gerald H. Jacobs, Photoreceptors and photopigments in a subterranean rodent, the pocket gopher (Thomomys bottae), Journal of Comparative Physiology A, 191, 2, (125), (2005).
- Y.Y. Schechner and N. Karpel, Recovery of Underwater Visibility and Structure by Polarization Analysis, IEEE Journal of Oceanic Engineering, 30, 3, (570), (2005).
- Leo Peichl, Pavel Němec and Hynek Burda, Unusual cone and rod properties in subterranean African mole‐rats (Rodentia, Bathyergidae), European Journal of Neuroscience, 19, 6, (1545-1558), (2004).
- Shoji Kawamura and Naoya Kubotera, Ancestral Loss of Short Wave-Sensitive Cone Visual Pigment in Lorisiform Prosimians, Contrasting with Its Strict Conservation in Other Prosimians, Journal of Molecular Evolution, 58, 3, (314), (2004).
- D. H. Levenson, S. A. Eckert, M. A. Crognale, J. F. Deegan, G. H. Jacobs and M. E. Douglas, Photopic Spectral Sensitivity of Green and Loggerhead Sea Turtles, Copeia, 2004, 4, (908), (2004).
- ALMUT KELBER, MISHA VOROBYEV and DANIEL OSORIO, Animal colour vision — behavioural tests and physiological concepts, Biological Reviews, 78, 1, (81-118), (2007).
- Gerald H. Jacobs, Comparative Psychology of Vision, Handbook of Psychology, (47-70), (2003).
- Petroc Sumner and J.D. Mollon, Colors of primate pelage and skin: Objective assessment of conspicuousness, American Journal of Primatology, 59, 2, (67-91), (2003).
- Nathaniel J Dominy, Jens-Christian Svenning and Wen-Hsiung Li, Historical contingency in the evolution of primate color vision, Journal of Human Evolution, 44, 1, (25), (2003).
- Sascha K. Hooker, Ian L. Boyd, Mark Jessopp, Oliver Cox, John Blackwell, Peter L. Boveng and John L. Bengtson, MONITORING THE PREY‐FIELD OF MARINE PREDATORS: COMBINING DIGITAL IMAGING WITH DATALOGGING TAGS, Marine Mammal Science, 18, 3, (680-697), (2006).
- Z. K. David‐Gray, J. Bellingham, M. Munoz, A. Avivi, E. Nevo and R. G. Foster, Adaptive loss of ultraviolet‐sensitive/violet‐sensitive (UVS/VS) cone opsin in the blind mole rat (Spalax ehrenbergi), European Journal of Neuroscience, 16, 7, (1186-1194), (2002).
- Ulrike Griebel and Axel Schmid, Spectral sensitivity and Color Vision in the Bottlenose Dolphin (Tursiops Truncatus), Marine and Freshwater Behaviour and Physiology, 35, 3, (129), (2002).
- Michael H. Rowe, Trichromatic Color Vision in Primates, Physiology, 17, 3, (93), (2002).
- Martin Glösmann and Peter K Ahnelt, A mouse-like retinal cone phenotype in the Syrian hamster: S opsin coexpressed with M opsin in a common cone photoreceptor, Brain Research, 929, 1, (139), (2002).
- Ouria Dkhissi‐Benyahya, Agoston Szel, Willem J. Degrip and Howard M. Cooper, Short and mid‐wavelength cone distribution in a nocturnal Strepsirrhine primate (Microcebus murinus), Journal of Comparative Neurology, 438, 4, (490-504), (2001).
- Robert W. Meredith, John Gatesy, Christopher A. Emerling, Vincent M. York, Mark S. Springer and Jianzhi Zhang, Rod Monochromacy and the Coevolution of Cetacean Retinal Opsins, PLoS Genetics, 10.1371/journal.pgen.1003432, 9, 4, (e1003432), (2013).
- Erich Pascal Malkemper and Leo Peichl, Retinal photoreceptor and ganglion cell types and topographies in the red fox () and Arctic fox (), Journal of Comparative Neurology, , (2018).
