ARTICLE
EXPERT FIXERS: Bureaucratic Informality, Brokerage and the Politics of Land in Mumbai
Sangeeta Banerji,
Sangeeta Banerji,
This project has received financial support from the Wenner Gren dissertation fieldwork grant (grant number 9517) and the Excellence fellowship from the Graduate School New Brunswick of the Rutgers University. Though they go here unnamed, I wish to thank many officials of the BMC and various professional liaisoners who let me enter their complex world of brokerage in Mumbai. I also thank Asher Ghertner, Thomas Crowley and Arif Hayat Nairang for their generous comments on earlier drafts of this article.
Abstract
Based on ethnographic fieldwork within the Brihanmumbai Municipal Corporation (BMC), this article illustrates the ‘field of fixing’, a brokerage structure that operates alongside Mumbai's urban bureaucracy. Scholars of Southern urbanism have extensively written about the role of informalized state action in producing an unequal cityscape. Exploring a disaggregated view of this state space in the megacity of Mumbai, this article turns attention instead to the ‘paralegal’ or the ‘field of fixing’, a liminal space between the state, market and society dictating access to the city in postcolonial India. The expert fixers in this space manipulate and maintain the real estate industry's relationship with Mumbai's urban bureaucracy. This article highlights the practices of six such fixers—the follow-up boy, the watcher, the paper expert, the regulation expert, the regulation strategy expert and the liaisoning architect by following the movement of files seeking bureaucratic approvals for land development in Mumbai, elucidating a predatory politics that ensures the success of real-estate developers in the megacity.
References
- Alpes, M.J. (2017) Papers that work: migration brokers, state/market boundaries, and the place of law. Political and Legal Anthropology Review 40.2, 262–77.
10.1111/plar.12219 Google Scholar
- Anand, N. (2017. Hydraulic city: water and the infrastructures of citizenship in Mumbai. Duke University Press, Durham, NC.
10.1215/9780822373599 Google Scholar
- Anjaria, J.S. (2011. Ordinary states: everyday corruption and the politics of space in Mumbai. American Ethnologist 38.1, 58–72.
10.1111/j.1548-1425.2010.01292.x Google Scholar
- Arendt, H. (1970) On violence. Harvest Books, New York, NY.
- Baghel, S. and C. Marpakwar. (2018) Controversy over tampered noting: civic body loses case, plot in SC. Mumbai Mirror, 19–21 [WWW document]. URL https://mumbaimirror.indiatimes.com/mumbai/civic/controversy-over-tampered-noting-civic-body-loses-case-plot-in-sc/articleshow/65156665.cms (accessed 18 December 2024).
- Bailey, F.G. (1957) Caste and the economic frontier: a village in highland Orissa. Manchester University Press, Manchester.
- Baliga, A. (2023) Chasing land, chasing crisis: interrogating speculative urban development through developers’ pursuit of land commodification in Mumbai. Environment and Planning A. 56.2, 349–66.
- Baliga, L. (2013) Public information officers to be responsible for missing files. Times of India, 1 August 2013 [WWW document]. URL https://timesofindia.indiatimes.com/city/mumbai/Public-information-officers-to-be-responsible-for-missing-files-BMC/articleshow/21518262.cms (accessed 18 December 2024).
- Banerji, S. (2021) Fixing Mumbai: broker-life, expertise, and technology in the urban bureaucracy. Dissertation for the School of Graduate Studies, Rutgers University, New Brunswick, NJ [WWW document]: URL https://doi.org/10.7282/t3-77nh-rc31 (accessed 18 December 2024).
10.7282/t3?77nh?rc31 Google Scholar
- Benjamin, S. (2008) Occupancy urbanism: radicalizing politics and economy beyond policy and programs. International Journal of Urban and Regional Research 32.3, 719–29.
- Berenschot, W. (2011) Political fixers and the rise of Hindu-nationalism in Gujarat, India: lubricating a patronage democracy. South Asia: Journal of South Asian Studies 34.3, 382–401.
10.1080/00856401.2011.620552 Google Scholar
- Bhargava, V. (2020) Mumbai's nearly trillion-dollar real estate market set to see greatest wealth erosion in history. Moneycontrol.com, 30 June [WWW document]. URL https://www.moneycontrol.com/europe/?url=https://www.moneycontrol.com/news/business/real-estate/mumbais-nearly-trillion-dollar-real-estate-market-set-to-see-greatest-wealth-erosion-in-history-5480531.html (accessed 19 December 2024).
- Bharucha, N. (2014). BMC babus’ bribe rate card for builders: Rs 1,200 a square feet [sic]. The Times of India, 24 October [WWW document]. URL https://timesofindia.indiatimes.com/city/mumbai/bmc-babus-bribe-rate-card-for-builders-rs-1200-a-square-feet/articleshow/44920563.cms (accessed 20 December 2024).
- Bhide, A. (2014) Mumbai—transforming city, transforming trajectories of violence. Tata Institute of Social Sciences, Mumbai.
- Björkman, L. (2014a) Becoming a slum: from municipal colony to illegal settlement in liberalization-era Mumbai. International Journal of Urban and Regional Research 38.1, 36–59.
- Björkman, L. (2014b) ‘You can't buy a vote’: meanings of money in a Mumbai election. American Ethnologist 41.4, 617–34.
10.1111/amet.12101 Google Scholar
- Bjorkman, L. (2015) Pipe politics, contested waters: embedded infrastructures of millennial Mumbai. Duke University Press, Durham, NC.
10.1215/9780822375210 Google Scholar
- Björkman, L. (2020) Waiting town: life in transit and Mumbai's other world-class histories. Asia Shorts Association for Asian Studies, Ann Arbor, MI.
- Björkman, L. (2021) Dalpat: manager of services. In L. Björkman (ed.), Bombay brokers: urban ethnography in the global interregnum, Duke University Press, Durham, NC.
10.1515/9781478013082-006 Google Scholar
- Bourdieu, P. (1977) Outline of a theory of practice. Cambridge University Press, Cambridge.
10.1017/CBO9780511812507 Google Scholar
- Bourdieu, P. and L. Wacquant (1992) An invitation to reflexive sociology. University of Chicago Press, Chicago, IL.
- Brenner, N. (2004) New state spaces: urban governance and the rescaling of statehood. Oxford University Press, Oxford.
10.1093/acprof:oso/9780199270057.001.0001 Google Scholar
- Chatterjee, P. (2004) The politics of the governed: reflections on popular politics in most of the world. Columbia University Press, New York, NY.
- Chatterjee, P. (2011) Lineages of political society: studies in postcolonial democracy. Cultures of History, Columbia University Press, New York, NY.
- Das, V. (2007) Life and words: violence and the descent into the ordinary. University of California Press, Berkeley, CA.
- Dobbin, C.E. (1972) Urban leadership in Western India: politics and communities in Bombay city, 1840–1885. Oxford Historical Monographs, Oxford University Press, Oxford.
- Dossal, M. (2005) A master plan for the city. Economic and Political Weekly 40.36, 3897–3900.
- Gandhi, S., V. Tandel, A. Tabarrok and S. Ravi. (2021) Too slow for the urban march: litigations and the real estate market in Mumbai, India. Journal of Urban Economics 123 (May) 103330.
- Geertz, C. (1960) The Javanese Kijaji: the changing role of a cultural broker. Comparative Studies in Society and History 2.2, 228–49.
10.1017/S0010417500000670 Google Scholar
- Ghertner, D.A. (2015) Rule by aesthetics: world-class city making in Delhi. Oxford University Press, Oxford.
10.1093/acprof:oso/9780199385560.001.0001 Google Scholar
- Ghertner, D.A. (2017) When is the state? Topology, temporality, and the navigation of everyday state space in Delhi. Annals of the American Association of Geographers 107. 3, 731–50.
10.1080/24694452.2016.1261680 Google Scholar
- Gidwani, V. and C. Upadhya. (2022) Articulation work: value chains of land assembly and real estate development on a peri-urban frontier. Environment and Planning A: Economy and Space 55.2, 407–27.
- Grenfell, M. (2010) Pierre Bourdieu: key concepts. Acumen Publishing Limited, Durham.
- Gupta, A. (2012). Red tape: bureaucracy, structural violence, and poverty in India. Duke University Press, Durham, NC.
10.1215/9780822394709 Google Scholar
- Hansen, T.B. and F. Stepputat. (2001) States of imagination: ethnographic explorations of the post colonial state. Duke University Press, Durham, NC.
10.1215/9780822381273 Google Scholar
- Harriss-White, B. (2004) India working: essays on society and economy. Oxford University Press, New York, NY.
- Harvey, D. (1985a) Consciousness and the urban experience: studies in the history and theory of capitalism. Johns Hopkins University Press, Baltimore, MD.
- Harvey, D. (1985b) The urbanization of capital. Johns Hopkins University Press, Baltimore, MD.
- Harvey, D. (2001) Globalization and the ‘spatial fix’. Geographische Revue 2, 23–30.
- Haynes, D.E., and N. Rao. (2013) Beyond the colonial city: re-evaluating the urban history of India, ca. 1920-1970. South Asia: Journal of South Asia Studies 36.3, 317–35.
10.1080/00856401.2013.814617 Google Scholar
- Hetherington, K. (2011) Guerrilla auditors: the politics of transparency in neoliberal Paraguay. Duke University Press, Durham, NC.
10.1215/9780822394266 Google Scholar
- Hull, M.S. (2012) Documents and bureaucracy. Annual Review of Anthropology 41, 251–67.
- Hull, M.S. (2013) Government of paper: materiality of bureaucracy in urban Pakistan. University of California Press, Los Angeles, CA.
- Issar, S. (2022) The financialisation of floor space, Mumbai 1880–2015. Urban Studies 59.15, 3150–66.
10.1177/00420980221076745 Google Scholar
- James, D. (2011) The return of the broker: consensus, hierarchy, and choice in South African land reform. Journal of Royal Anthropological Institute 17, 318–38.
- Jeffrey, C., C. Philliou, D. Rogers and A. Shryock. (2011) Fixers in motion: a conversation. Comparative Studies in Society and History 53.3, 692–707.
10.1017/S0010417511000302 Google Scholar
- Jeffrey, C. and S. Young. (2014) Jugad: youth and enterprise in India. Annals of the Association of American Geographers 104.1, 182–95.
10.1080/00045608.2013.847757 Google Scholar
- Jonnalagadda, I. (2022) Of political entrepreneurs: assembling community and social capital in Hyderabad's informal settlements. Urban Studies 59.4, 717–33.
10.1177/00420980211014120 Google Scholar
- Kamath, L. and M. Joseph. (2015) How a participatory process can matter in planning the city. Economic and Political Weekly 50.39, 54–61.
- Khandekar, C.V. (2013) Building collapses: owning the problem. Economic and Political Weekly 48.45, 30–32.
- Koster, M. (2012) Mediating and getting ‘burnt’ in the gap: politics and brokerage in a Recife Slum, Brazil. Critique of Anthropology 32.4, 479–97.
10.1177/0308275X12456643 Google Scholar
- Koster, M. and Y. van Leynseele. (2018) Brokers as assemblers: studying development through the lens of brokerage. Ethnos 83.5, 803–13.
10.1080/00141844.2017.1362451 Google Scholar
- Krishnan, S. (2016) When Donald Trump came to Mumbai. Economic and Political Weekly 51.23, 34-9.
- La Hausse, P. (1992) So who was Elias Kuzwayo? Nationalism, collaboration and the picaresque in Natal. Cahiers d'Études Africaines 32, 469–507.
10.3406/cea.1992.1545 Google Scholar
- Latour, B. and S. Woolgar. (1986) Laboratory life: the construction of scientific facts. Princeton University Press, Princeton, NJ.
- Levien, M. (2018) Dispossession without development: land grabs in neoliberal India. Modern South Asia, Oxford University Press, New York, NY.
10.1093/oso/9780190859152.001.0001 Google Scholar
- Lindquist, J. (2012) The elementary school teacher, the thug and his grandmother: informal brokers and transnational migration from Indonesia. Pacific Affairs 85.1, 115–33.
- Lund, C. (2006) Twilight institutions: public authority and local politics in Africa. Development and Change 37.4, 685–705.
10.1111/j.1467-7660.2006.00497.x Google Scholar
- Manor, J. (2000) Small-time political fixers in India's states: ‘towel over armpit’. Asian Survey 40.5, 816–35.
10.2307/3021178 Google Scholar
- Marpakwar, C. (2018) Kamala mills fire: restaurants shown as office canteens reveals BMC Probe. Mumbai Mirror, 28 March 2018 [WWW document]. URL https://mumbaimirror.indiatimes.com/mumbai/cover-story/restaurants-shown-as-office-canteens/articleshow/63495315.cms (accessed 19 December 2024).
- Mathur, N. (2016) Paper tiger: law, bureaucracy and the developmental state in Himalayan India. Cambridge University Press, New Delhi.
10.1017/CBO9781316227367 Google Scholar
- Nainan, N.K.B. (2012) Lakshmi Raj—shaping spaces in post-industrial Mumbai: urban regimes, planning instruments and splintering communities. PhD dissertation, Faculty of Social and Behavioural Sciences, University of Amsterdam.
- Nair, S. (2012) BMC mulls annual review of development plan implementation. The Indian Express, 23 February 2012 [WWW document]. URL https://indianexpress.com/article/cities/mumbai/bmc-mulls-annual-review-of-development-plan-implementation/ (accessed 19 December 2024).
- Nijman, J. (2000) Mumbai's real estate market in 1990's: de-regulation, global money and casino capitalism. Economic and Political Weekly 35.7, 575–82.
- Painter, J. (2006) Prosaic geographies of stateness. Political Geography 25.7, 752–74.
10.1016/j.polgeo.2006.07.004 Google Scholar
- Raman, B. (2012) Document Raj: writing and scribes in early colonial South India. South Asia Across the Disciplines, University of Chicago Press, Chicago, IL.
10.7208/chicago/9780226703299.001.0001 Google Scholar
- Reddy, G.R. and G. Haragopal (1985) Public policy and he rural poor in India: a study of SFDA in Andrah Pradesh. Concept Publishing Company, New Delhi.
- Roy, A. (2003) City requiem, Calcutta: gender and the politics of poverty. Globalization and Community, University of Minnesota Press, Minneapolis, MN.
- Roy, A. (2009) Why India cannot plan its cities: informality, insurgence and the idiom of urbanization. Planning Theory 8.1, 76–87.
- Roy, A. (2011) Slumdog cities: rethinking subaltern urbanism. International Journal of Urban and Regional Research 35.2, 223–38.
- Scott, J.C. (1976) The moral economy of the peasant. Yale University Press, New Haven, CT.
- Searle, L.G. (2018) The contradictions of mediation: intermediaries and the financialization of urban production. Economy and Society 47.4, 524–46.
10.1080/03085147.2018.1538638 Google Scholar
- Seekings, J. and N. Nattrass. (2005) Class, race, and inequality in South Africa. Yale University Press, New Haven, CT.
10.12987/yale/9780300108927.001.0001 Google Scholar
- Shah, D. (2013) Files of Bandra: Jogeshwari Buildings missing from the BMC. Redevelopment of Housing Society [WWW document]. URL https://www.redevelopmentofhousingsociety.com/index.php/realty-frauds-scams/125-files-of-bandra-jogeshwari-missing-from-bmc#:~:text=It%20is%20alleged%20that%20Developers,build%20three%20additional%20illegal%20floors (accessed 20 December 2024).
- Sharma, R.N. (2010) Mega transformation of Mumbai: deepening enclave urbanism. Sociological Bulletin 59.1, 69–91.
10.1177/0038022920100104 Google Scholar
- Siddiqi, F.J. (2013) Governing urban land: the political economy of the ULCRA in Mumbai. Master's thesis, Department of Urban Studies and Planning, Massachusetts Institute of Technology.
- Singh, D. (2018a) Jogeshwari land scam: four BMC officials suspended, 14 to face probes by department. The Indian Express, 22 August [WWW document]. URL https://indianexpress.com/article/cities/mumbai/jogeshwari-land-scam-four-bmc-officials-suspended-14-to-face-probes-by-dept-5318297/ (accessed 19 December 2024).
- Singh, D. (2018b) Kamala Mills fire: BMC chief orders crackdown on ‘nexus’ between complainants and officials. The Indian Express, 2 January [WWW document]. https://indianexpress.com/article/cities/mumbai/kamala-mills-fire-bmc-chief-orders-crackdown-on-nexus-between-complainants-and-officials-5008076/ (accessed 19 December 2024).
- Sud, N. (2014). Governing India's land. World Development 60, 43–56.
- Sundaresan, J. (2019) Urban planning in vernacular governance: land use planning and violations in Bangalore, India. Progress in Planning 127 (January), 1–23.
- Tandel, V., S. Gandhi and A, Tabarrok. (2023) Building networks: investigating the quid pro quo between local politicians and developers. Journal of Development Economics 164 (September), 103138.
10.1016/j.jdeveco.2023.103138 Google Scholar
- Wang, Y. (2016) Homology and isomorphism: Bourdieu in conversation with new institutionalism. British Journal of Sociology 67.2, 348–70.
10.1111/1468-4446.12197 Google Scholar
- Weber, M. (1958) The Protestant ethic and the spirit of capitalism. Charles Scribner's Sons, New York, NY.
- Weinstein, L. (2014a) ‘One-man handled’: fragmented power and political entrepreneurship in globalizing Mumbai. International Journal of Urban and Regional Research 38.1, 14–35.
10.1111/1468-2427.12040 Google Scholar
- Weinstein, L. (2014b) The durable slum. Minnesota University Press, Minneapolis, MN.
- Willis, R. (2019) The use of composite narratives to present interview findings. Qualitative Research 19.4, 471–80.
10.1177/1468794118787711 Google Scholar
- Wolf, E.R. (1956) Aspects of group relations in a complex society: Mexico. American Anthropologist 58.6, 1065–78.
10.1525/aa.1956.58.6.02a00070 Google Scholar
- World Bank. (2018) Doing business 2018—reforming to create jobs. World Bank. The World Bank, Washington DC.
10.1596/978-1-4648-1146-3 Google Scholar
- Zamora, G. (2023) The cities with the most billionaires 2023. Forbes, 8 April. [WWW document]. URL https://www.forbes.com/sites/gigizamora/2023/04/08/the-cities-with-the-most-billionaires-2023/ (accessed 19 December 2025).
