RACIAL PROFILING OR RACIST POLICING? BOUNDS TESTS IN AGGREGATE DATA*
Abstract
State‐wide reports on police traffic stops and searches summarize very large populations, making them potentially powerful tools for identifying racial bias, particularly when statistics on search outcomes are included. But when the reported statistics conflate searches involving different levels of police discretion, standard tests for racial bias are not applicable. This article develops a model of police search decisions that allows for nondiscretionary searches and derives tests for racial bias in data that mix different search types. Our tests reject unbiased policing as an explanation of the disparate impact of motor‐vehicle searches on minorities in Missouri.
Citing Literature
Number of times cited according to CrossRef: 44
- Matthew C. Matusiak, Michael R. Cavanaugh, Matthew Stephenson, An Assessment of Officer-Involved Shooting Data Transparency in the United States, Journal of Interpersonal Violence, 10.1177/0886260520913646, (088626052091364), (2020).
- Murat C Mungan, Discrimination and Deterrence with Enforcer Liability, American Law and Economics Review, 10.1093/aler/ahaa007, (2020).
- Dawson G. Eiserloh, Jeremy J. Foreman, Elizabeth C. Heintz, Racial Bias in National Football League Officiating, Frontiers in Sociology, 10.3389/fsoc.2020.00048, 5, (2020).
- Allison P. Harris, Elliott Ash, Jeffrey Fagan, Fiscal Pressures and Discriminatory Policing: Evidence from Traffic Stops in Missouri, The Journal of Race, Ethnicity, and Politics, 10.1017/rep.2020.10, (1-31), (2020).
- George Bulman, LAW ENFORCEMENT LEADERS AND THE RACIAL COMPOSITION OF ARRESTS, Economic Inquiry, 10.1111/ecin.12800, 57, 4, (1842-1858), (2019).
- Jonathan Mummolo, Modern Police Tactics, Police-Citizen Interactions, and the Prospects for Reform, The Journal of Politics, 10.1086/694393, 80, 1, (1-15), (2018).
- Murat C Mungan, Statistical (and Racial) Discrimination, “Ban the Box”, and Crime Rates, American Law and Economics Review, 10.1093/aler/ahy008, (2018).
- Petra E. Todd, Racial Profiling, The New Palgrave Dictionary of Economics, 10.1057/978-1-349-95121-5, (1-10), (2017).
- Joseph A. Ritter, How do police use race in traffic stops and searches? Tests based on observability of race, Journal of Economic Behavior & Organization, 10.1016/j.jebo.2017.02.005, 135, (82-98), (2017).
- Turgut Ozkan, John L. Worrall, Alex R. Piquero, Does Minority Representation in Police Agencies Reduce Assaults on the Police?, American Journal of Criminal Justice, 10.1007/s12103-016-9338-6, 41, 3, (402-423), (2016).
- Kyle McLean, Jeff Rojek, Traffic Stops, Race, and Measurement, The Handbook of Measurement Issues in Criminology and Criminal Justice, 10.1002/9781118868799, (452-472), (2016).
- Yu-Wei Luke Chu, Do Medical Marijuana Laws Increase Hard-Drug Use?, The Journal of Law and Economics, 10.1086/684043, 58, 2, (481-517), (2015).
- Decio Coviello, Nicola Persico, An Economic Analysis of Black-White Disparities in the New York Police Department’s Stop-and-Frisk Program, The Journal of Legal Studies, 10.1086/684292, 44, 2, (315-360), (2015).
- CHRISTOPHER COTTON, CHENG LI, Profiling, Screening, and Criminal Recruitment, Journal of Public Economic Theory, 10.1111/jpet.12115, 17, 6, (964-985), (2015).
- Michael Roach, Is the Highway Patrol Really Tougher on Out-of-State Drivers? An Empirical Analysis, The B.E. Journal of Economic Analysis & Policy, 10.1515/bejeap-2014-0011, 15, 2, (2015).
- S. Sanga, Does Officer Race Matter?, American Law and Economics Review, 10.1093/aler/ahu004, 16, 2, (403-432), (2014).
- BRADY P. HORN, JILL J. MCCLUSKEY, RON C. MITTELHAMMER, QUANTIFYING BIAS IN DRIVING‐UNDER‐THE‐INFLUENCE ENFORCEMENT, Economic Inquiry, 10.1111/ecin.12043, 52, 1, (269-284), (2013).
- Philippe Barbe, William C. Horrace, A Critical Reanalysis of Maryland State Police Searches, The American Statistician, 10.1080/00031305.2012.663662, 66, 1, (1-7), (2012).
- George E. Higgins, Gennaro F. Vito, Elizabeth L. Grossi, Anthony G. Vito, Searches and Traffic Stops: Racial Profiling and Capriciousness, Journal of Ethnicity in Criminal Justice, 10.1080/15377938.2012.700622, 10, 3, (163-179), (2012).
- George E. Higgins, Gennaro F. Vito, Elizabeth L. Grossi, The Impact of Race on the Police Decision to Search During a Traffic Stop, Journal of Contemporary Criminal Justice, 10.1177/1043986211425725, 28, 2, (166-183), (2011).
- Rob Tillyer, Charles Klahm, Searching for Contraband: Assessing the Use of Discretion by Police Officers, Police Quarterly, 10.1177/1098611111404178, 14, 2, (166-185), (2011).
- Garrick Blalock, Jed DeVaro, Stephanie Leventhal, Daniel H. Simon, Gender bias in power relationships: evidence from police traffic stops, Applied Economics, 10.1080/00036846.2010.491467, 43, 29, (4469-4485), (2011).
- Anthony Hoskin, Explaining the Link Between Race and Violence With General Strain Theory, Journal of Ethnicity in Criminal Justice, 10.1080/15377938.2011.535471, 9, 1, (56-73), (2011).
- Rob Tillyer, Robin S. Engel, Jennifer Calnon Cherkauskas, Best practices in vehicle stop data collection and analysis, Policing: An International Journal of Police Strategies & Management, 10.1108/13639511011020601, 33, 1, (69-92), (2010).
- Paul Heaton, Understanding the Effects of Antiprofiling Policies, The Journal of Law and Economics, 10.1086/649645, 53, 1, (29-64), (2010).
- Laura J. Khoury, Racial profiling as dressage : a social control regime! , African Identities, 10.1080/14725840802583314, 7, 1, (55-70), (2009).
- Kate Antonovics, Brian G Knight, A New Look at Racial Profiling: Evidence from the Boston Police Department, Review of Economics and Statistics, 10.1162/rest.91.1.163, 91, 1, (163-177), (2009).
- Nicola Persico, Racial Profiling? Detecting Bias Using Statistical Evidence, Annual Review of Economics, 10.1146/annurev.economics.050708.143307, 1, 1, (229-254), (2009).
- Greg Ridgeway, John M. MacDonald, Doubly Robust Internal Benchmarking and False Discovery Rates for Detecting Racial Bias in Police Stops, Journal of the American Statistical Association, 10.1198/jasa.2009.0034, 104, 486, (661-668), (2009).
- Sarath Sanga, Reconsidering Racial Bias in Motor Vehicle Searches: Theory and Evidence, Journal of Political Economy, 10.1086/649800, 117, 6, (1155-1159), (2009).
- Thomas A. Garrett, Gary A. Wagner, Red Ink in the Rearview Mirror: Local Fiscal Conditions and the Issuance of Traffic Tickets, The Journal of Law and Economics, 10.1086/589702, 52, 1, (71-90), (2009).
- Robin S. Engel, Rob Tillyer, Searching for Equilibrium: The Tenuous Nature of the Outcome Test, Justice Quarterly, 10.1080/07418820701717243, 25, 1, (54-71), (2008).
- Brian N. Williams, Michael Stahl, An analysis of police traffic stops and searches in Kentucky: a mixed methods approach offering heuristic and practical implications, Policy Sciences, 10.1007/s11077-008-9065-z, 41, 3, (221-243), (2008).
- Tomer Blumkin, Yoram Margalioth, On terror, drugs and racial profiling, International Review of Law and Economics, 10.1016/j.irle.2008.06.002, 28, 3, (194-203), (2008).
- Helle Bunzel, Philippe Marcoul, Can racially unbiased police perpetuate long-run discrimination?, Journal of Economic Behavior & Organization, 10.1016/j.jebo.2006.02.011, 68, 1, (36-47), (2008).
- Harold Winter, References, The Economics of Crime, 10.4324/9780203927465, (117-129), (2008).
- Robin S. Engel, A Critique of the “Outcome Test” in Racial Profiling Research, Justice Quarterly, 10.1080/07418820701717177, 25, 1, (1-36), (2008).
- Jennifer A. Varriale, Jennifer C. Gibbs, Eileen M. Ahlin, Mathew R. Gugino, Chongmin Na, Trends in Police Research: A Cross‐Sectional Analysis of the 2004 Literature, Police Practice and Research, 10.1080/15614260701764330, 8, 5, (461-485), (2007).
- DAVID BJERK, Racial Profiling, Statistical Discrimination, and the Effect of a Colorblind Policy on the Crime Rate, Journal of Public Economic Theory, 10.1111/j.1467-9779.2007.00318.x, 9, 3, (521-545), (2007).
- Jack Glaser, The efficacy and effect of racial profiling: A mathematical simulation approach, Journal of Policy Analysis and Management, 10.1002/pam.20178, 25, 2, (395-416), (2006).
- Shamena Anwar, Hanming Fang, An Alternative Test of Racial Prejudice in Motor Vehicle Searches: Theory and Evidence, American Economic Review, 10.1257/000282806776157579, 96, 1, (127-151), (2006).
- Nicola G. Persico, Petra Todd, Passenger Profiling, Imperfect Screening, and Airport Security, SSRN Electronic Journal, 10.2139/ssrn.651881, (2005).
- Nicola Persico, Petra E Todd, Passenger Profiling, Imperfect Screening, and Airport Security, American Economic Review, 10.1257/000282805774670031, 95, 2, (127-131), (2005).
- Antonio Merlo, INTRODUCTION TO ECONOMIC MODELS OF CRIME, International Economic Review, 10.1111/j.0020-6598.2004.00282.x, 45, 3, (677-679), (2004).
