A comparison of spatially explicit landscape representation methods and their relationship to stream condition
Erin E. Peterson, CSIRO Division of Mathematics, Informatics and Statistics, 120 Meiers Rd., Indooroopilly, Qld 4068, Australia. E‐mail: erin.peterson@csiro.au
Summary
1. Biodiversity, water quality and ecosystem processes in streams are known to be influenced by the terrestrial landscape over a range of spatial and temporal scales. Lumped attributes (i.e. per cent land use) are often used to characterise the condition of the catchment; however, they are not spatially explicit and do not account for the disproportionate influence of land located near the stream or connected by overland flow.
2. We compared seven landscape representation metrics to determine whether accounting for the spatial proximity and hydrological effects of land use can be used to account for additional variability in indicators of stream ecosystem health. The landscape metrics included the following: a lumped metric, four inverse‐distance‐weighted (IDW) metrics based on distance to the stream or survey site and two modified IDW metrics that also accounted for the level of hydrologic activity (HA‐IDW). Ecosystem health data were obtained from the Ecological Health Monitoring Programme in Southeast Queensland, Australia and included measures of fish, invertebrates, physicochemistry and nutrients collected during two seasons over 4 years. Linear models were fitted to the stream indicators and landscape metrics, by season, and compared using an information‐theoretic approach.
3. Although no single metric was most suitable for modelling all stream indicators, lumped metrics rarely performed as well as other metric types. Metrics based on proximity to the stream (IDW and HA‐IDW) were more suitable for modelling fish indicators, while the HA‐IDW metric based on proximity to the survey site generally outperformed others for invertebrates, irrespective of season. There was consistent support for metrics based on proximity to the survey site (IDW or HA‐IDW) for all physicochemical indicators during the dry season, while a HA‐IDW metric based on proximity to the stream was suitable for five of the six physicochemical indicators in the post‐wet season. Only one nutrient indicator was tested and results showed that catchment area had a significant effect on the relationship between land use metrics and algal stable isotope ratios in both seasons.
4. Spatially explicit methods of landscape representation can clearly improve the predictive ability of many empirical models currently used to study the relationship between landscape, habitat and stream condition. A comparison of different metrics may provide clues about causal pathways and mechanistic processes behind correlative relationships and could be used to target restoration efforts strategically.
Citing Literature
Number of times cited according to CrossRef: 58
- Chaogui Lei, Paul D. Wagner, Nicola Fohrer, Effects of land cover, topography, and soil on stream water quality at multiple spatial and seasonal scales in a German lowland catchment, Ecological Indicators, 10.1016/j.ecolind.2020.106940, 120, (106940), (2021).
- Janardan Mainali, Heejun Chang, Putting space into modeling landscape and water quality relationships in the Han River basin, South Korea, Computers, Environment and Urban Systems, 10.1016/j.compenvurbsys.2020.101461, 81, (101461), (2020).
- Craig D. Snyder, John A. Young, Identification of management thresholds of urban development in support of aquatic biodiversity conservation, Ecological Indicators, 10.1016/j.ecolind.2020.106124, 112, (106124), (2020).
- Kai Ma, Xiaorong Huang, Chuan Liang, Hongbin Zhao, Xingyu Zhou, Xiaoyue Wei, Effect of land use/cover changes on runoff in the Min River watershed, River Research and Applications, 10.1002/rra.3608, 36, 5, (749-759), (2020).
- Coulibaly Thierry Yerema, Mihoko Wakamatsu, Moinul Islam, Fukai Hiroki, Shunsuke Managi, Bingqi Zhang, Differences in Water Policy Efficacy across South African Water Management Areas, Ecological Economics, 10.1016/j.ecolecon.2020.106707, 175, (106707), (2020).
- Ewane Basil Ewane, Assessing land use and landscape factors as determinants of water quality trends in Nyong River basin, Cameroon, Environmental Monitoring and Assessment, 10.1007/s10661-020-08448-2, 192, 8, (2020).
- Kelsey B. Aho, Joseph E. Flotemersch, Scott G. Leibowitz, Matthew A. LaCroix, Marc H. Weber, Applying the index of watershed integrity to the Matanuska–Susitna basin, Arctic, Antarctic, and Alpine Research, 10.1080/15230430.2020.1800219, 52, 1, (435-449), (2020).
- Nolan J.T. Pearce, Adam G. Yates, Spatial and temporal patterns in macronutrient concentrations and stoichiometry of tributaries draining the lower Great Lakes-St. Lawrence basin, Journal of Great Lakes Research, 10.1016/j.jglr.2020.05.002, (2020).
- Mischa P. Turschwell, Ben Stewart-Koster, Stephen R. Balcombe, Fran Sheldon, Erin E. Peterson, Multiscale relationships between stream temperature and juvenile recruitment in an imperilled freshwater fish, Marine and Freshwater Research, 10.1071/MF19149, 71, 10, (1269), (2020).
- Janos J. Bogardi, Jan Leentvaar, Zita Sebesvári, Biologia Futura: integrating freshwater ecosystem health in water resources management, Biologia Futura, 10.1007/s42977-020-00031-7, (2020).
- Remington J. Moll, Jonathon D. Cepek, Patrick D. Lorch, Patricia M. Dennis, Terry Robison, Robert A. Montgomery, At what spatial scale(s) do mammals respond to urbanization?, Ecography, 10.1111/ecog.04762, 43, 2, (171-183), (2019).
- Fran Sheldon, Catherine Leigh, Wendy Neilan, Michael Newham, Carolyn Polson, Wade Hadwen, Urbanization, Approaches to Water Sensitive Urban Design, 10.1016/B978-0-12-812843-5.00011-3, (229-248), (2019).
- Linda R. Staponites, Vojtěch Barták, Michal Bílý, Ondřej P. Simon, Performance of landscape composition metrics for predicting water quality in headwater catchments, Scientific Reports, 10.1038/s41598-019-50895-6, 9, 1, (2019).
- Catherine Leigh, Sevvandi Kandanaarachchi, James M. McGree, Rob J. Hyndman, Omar Alsibai, Kerrie Mengersen, Erin E. Peterson, Predicting sediment and nutrient concentrations from high-frequency water-quality data, PLOS ONE, 10.1371/journal.pone.0215503, 14, 8, (e0215503), (2019).
- Adrien Ickowicz, Jessica Ford, Keith Hayes, A Mixture Model Approach for Compositional Data: Inferring Land-Use Influence on Point-Referenced Water Quality Measurements, Journal of Agricultural, Biological and Environmental Statistics, 10.1007/s13253-019-00371-5, (2019).
- Janardan Mainali, Heejun Chang, Yongwan Chun, A review of spatial statistical approaches to modeling water quality, Progress in Physical Geography: Earth and Environment, 10.1177/0309133319852003, (030913331985200), (2019).
- Lucy Baker, Michelle A. Evans-White, Sally Entrekin, Basin risk explains patterns of macroinvertebrate community differences across small streams in the Fayetteville Shale, AR, Ecological Indicators, 10.1016/j.ecolind.2018.03.049, 91, (478-489), (2018).
- Ana L. Liberoff, Silvia Flaherty, Pablo Hualde, Martín I. García Asorey, Marilyn L. Fogel, Miguel A. Pascual, Assessing land use and land cover influence on surface water quality using a parametric weighted distance function, Limnologica, 10.1016/j.limno.2018.10.003, (2018).
- Sally A. Entrekin, Bradley J. Austin, Michelle A. Evans-White, Brian E. Haggard, Establishing the linkages among watershed threats, in-stream alterations and biological responses remains a challenge: Fayetteville Shale as a case study, Current Opinion in Environmental Science & Health, 10.1016/j.coesh.2018.03.006, 3, (27-32), (2018).
- Janardan Mainali, Heejun Chang, Landscape and anthropogenic factors affecting spatial patterns of water quality trends in a large river basin, South Korea, Journal of Hydrology, 10.1016/j.jhydrol.2018.06.074, 564, (26-40), (2018).
- Bradley J. Austin, Julia E. Kelso, Michelle A. Evans-White, Sally A. Entrekin, Brian E. Haggard, Can high volume hydraulic fracturing effects be detected in large watersheds? A case study of the South Fork Little Red River, Current Opinion in Environmental Science & Health, 10.1016/j.coesh.2018.04.003, 3, (40-46), (2018).
- Anna Astorga, Paulo Moreno, Brian Reid, Watersheds and Trees Fall Together: An Analysis of Intact Forested Watersheds in Southern Patagonia (41–56° S), Forests, 10.3390/f9070385, 9, 7, (385), (2018).
- Jeremy P. Grimstead, Edward M. Krynak, Adam G. Yates, Scale-specific land cover thresholds for conservation of stream invertebrate communities in agricultural landscapes, Landscape Ecology, 10.1007/s10980-018-0738-5, (2018).
- A. Lintern, J.A. Webb, D. Ryu, S. Liu, U. Bende‐Michl, D. Waters, P. Leahy, P. Wilson, A. W. Western, Key factors influencing differences in stream water quality across space, Wiley Interdisciplinary Reviews: Water, 10.1002/wat2.1260, 5, 1, (2017).
- Laura L. Sosa, Helen C. Glanville, Miles R. Marshall, Sinan A. Abood, A. Prysor Williams, Davey L. Jones, Delineating and mapping riparian areas for ecosystem service assessment, Ecohydrology, 10.1002/eco.1928, 11, 2, (2017).
- Mischa P. Turschwell, Ben Stewart‐Koster, Catherine Leigh, Erin E. Peterson, Fran Sheldon, Stephen R. Balcombe, Riparian restoration offsets predicted population consequences of climate warming in a threatened headwater fish, Aquatic Conservation: Marine and Freshwater Ecosystems, 10.1002/aqc.2864, 28, 3, (575-586), (2017).
- Eric Craig Watson, Heejun Chang, Relation Between Stream Temperature and Landscape Characteristics Using Distance Weighted Metrics, Water Resources Management, 10.1007/s11269-017-1861-9, 32, 3, (1167-1192), (2017).
- Erqi Xu, Hongqi Zhang, A model for integrated spatial land use characteristics linking to surface nutrient concentration, International Journal of Digital Earth, 10.1080/17538947.2017.1373868, 11, 10, (1064-1084), (2017).
- Mariana C. Molina, Camilo A. Roa-Fuentes, Jaquelini O. Zeni, Lilian Casatti, The effects of land use at different spatial scales on instream features in agricultural streams, Limnologica, 10.1016/j.limno.2017.06.001, 65, (14-21), (2017).
- Daniel J. Isaak, Jay M. Ver Hoef, Erin E. Peterson, Dona L. Horan, David E. Nagel, Scalable population estimates using spatial-stream-network (SSN) models, fish density surveys, and national geospatial database frameworks for streams, Canadian Journal of Fisheries and Aquatic Sciences, 10.1139/cjfas-2016-0247, 74, 2, (147-156), (2017).
- Lijuan Cui, Wei Li, Changjun Gao, Manyin Zhang, Xinsheng Zhao, Zheng Yang, Yinru Lei, Di Huang, Wu Ma, Identifying the influence factors at multiple scales on river water chemistry in the Tiaoxi Basin, China, Ecological Indicators, 10.1016/j.ecolind.2017.08.053, (2017).
- F.L. Jackson, David M. Hannah, R.J. Fryer, C.P. Millar, I.A. Malcolm, Development of spatial regression models for predicting summer river temperatures from landscape characteristics: Implications for land and fisheries management, Hydrological Processes, 10.1002/hyp.11087, 31, 6, (1225-1238), (2017).
- Miriam R. Johnston, Andrew J. Elmore, Karel Mokany, Matthew Lisk, Matthew C. Fitzpatrick, Field‐measured variables outperform derived alternatives in Maryland stream biodiversity models, Diversity and Distributions, 10.1111/ddi.12598, 23, 9, (1054-1066), (2017).
- Erin E. Peterson, Alan R. Pearse, IDW‐Plus: An ArcGIS Toolset for Calculating Spatially Explicit Watershed Attributes for Survey Sites, JAWRA Journal of the American Water Resources Association, 10.1111/1752-1688.12558, 53, 5, (1241-1249), (2017).
- Mischa P. Turschwell, Stephen R. Balcombe, E. Ashley Steel, Fran Sheldon, Erin E. Peterson, Thermal habitat restricts patterns of occurrence in multiple life-stages of a headwater fish, Freshwater Science, 10.1086/691553, 36, 2, (402-414), (2017).
- Paul Miguet, Lenore Fahrig, Claire Lavigne, How to quantify a distance‐dependent landscape effect on a biological response, Methods in Ecology and Evolution, 10.1111/2041-210X.12830, 8, 12, (1717-1724), (2017).
- Xiang Tan, Quanfa Zhang, Michele A. Burford, Fran Sheldon, Stuart E. Bunn, Benthic Diatom Based Indices for Water Quality Assessment in Two Subtropical Streams, Frontiers in Microbiology, 10.3389/fmicb.2017.00601, 8, (2017).
- P. M. Rose, M. J. Kennard, F. Sheldon, D. B. Moffatt, G. L. Butler, A data-driven method for selecting candidate reference sites for stream bioassessment programs using generalised dissimilarity models, Marine and Freshwater Research, 10.1071/MF14254, 67, 4, (440), (2016).
- Zbigniew J. Grabowski, Eric Watson, Heejun Chang, Using spatially explicit indicators to investigate watershed characteristics and stream temperature relationships, Science of The Total Environment, 10.1016/j.scitotenv.2016.02.042, 551-552, (376-386), (2016).
- Mischa P. Turschwell, Erin E. Peterson, Stephen R. Balcombe, Fran Sheldon, To aggregate or not? Capturing the spatio-temporal complexity of the thermal regime, Ecological Indicators, 10.1016/j.ecolind.2016.02.014, 67, (39-48), (2016).
- Erqi Xu, Hongqi Zhang, Aggregating land use quantity and intensity to link water quality in upper catchment of Miyun Reservoir, Ecological Indicators, 10.1016/j.ecolind.2016.02.002, 66, (329-339), (2016).
- Cassandra S. James, Stephen J. Mackay, Angela H. Arthington, Samantha J. Capon, Anna Barnes, Ben Pearson, Does stream flow structure woody riparian vegetation in subtropical catchments?, Ecology and Evolution, 10.1002/ece3.2249, 6, 16, (5950-5963), (2016).
- Thibault Datry, Herve Pella, Catherine Leigh, Núria Bonada, Bernard Hugueny, A landscape approach to advance intermittent river ecology, Freshwater Biology, 10.1111/fwb.12645, 61, 8, (1200-1213), (2016).
- Christopher J. Walsh, J. Angus Webb, Interactive effects of urban stormwater drainage, land clearance, and flow regime on stream macroinvertebrate assemblages across a large metropolitan region, Freshwater Science, 10.1086/685105, 35, 1, (324-339), (2016).
- Steven A. Loiselle, Davi Gasparini Fernandes Cunha, Scott Shupe, Elsa Valiente, Luciana Rocha, Eleanore Heasley, Patricia Pérez Belmont, Avinoam Baruch, Micro and Macroscale Drivers of Nutrient Concentrations in Urban Streams in South, Central and North America, PLOS ONE, 10.1371/journal.pone.0162684, 11, 9, (e0162684), (2016).
- Ryan A. Hill, Marc H. Weber, Scott G. Leibowitz, Anthony R. Olsen, Darren J. Thornbrugh, The Stream‐Catchment (StreamCat) Dataset: A Database of Watershed Metrics for the Conterminous United States, JAWRA Journal of the American Water Resources Association, 10.1111/1752-1688.12372, 52, 1, (120-128), (2015).
- Kris Van Looy, Jérémy Piffady, Thierry Tormos, Bertrand Villeneuve, Laurent Valette, André Chandesris, Yves Souchon, Unravelling River System Impairments in Stream Networks with an Integrated Risk Approach, Environmental Management, 10.1007/s00267-015-0477-1, 55, 6, (1343-1353), (2015).
- Virgilio Hermoso, Francis Pantus, Jon Olley, Simon Linke, James Mugodo, Patrick Lea, Prioritising catchment rehabilitation for multi objective management: An application from SE-Queensland, Australia, Ecological Modelling, 10.1016/j.ecolmodel.2015.08.017, 316, (168-175), (2015).
- Toni Furlonge, Fiona Dyer, Jenny Davis, The influence of differing protected area status and environmental factors on the macroinvertebrate fauna of temperate austral wetlands, Global Ecology and Conservation, 10.1016/j.gecco.2015.07.007, 4, (277-290), (2015).
- V. Vyšná, F. Dyer, W. Maher, R. Norris, Organic carbon reservoirs in five small rivers across a land-use gradient, Marine and Freshwater Research, 10.1071/MF13142, 66, 3, (233), (2015).
- Christopher J. Walsh, J. Angus Webb, Spatial weighting of land use and temporal weighting of antecedent discharge improves prediction of stream condition, Landscape Ecology, 10.1007/s10980-014-0050-y, 29, 7, (1171-1185), (2014).
- T. Tormos, K. Van Looy, B. Villeneuve, P. Kosuth, Y. Souchon, High resolution land cover data improve understanding of mechanistic linkages with stream integrity, Freshwater Biology, 10.1111/fwb.12377, 59, 8, (1721-1734), (2014).
- Felicity A. Edwards, David P. Edwards, Sean Sloan, Keith C. Hamer, Sustainable Management in Crop Monocultures: The Impact of Retaining Forest on Oil Palm Yield, PLoS ONE, 10.1371/journal.pone.0091695, 9, 3, (e91695), (2014).
- A. G. Yates, R. B. Brua, J. Corriveau, J. M. Culp, P. A. Chambers, SEASONALLY DRIVEN VARIATION IN SPATIAL RELATIONSHIPS BETWEEN AGRICULTURAL LAND USE AND IN‐STREAM NUTRIENT CONCENTRATIONS, River Research and Applications, 10.1002/rra.2646, 30, 4, (476-493), (2013).
- Titus S. Seilheimer, Patrick L. Zimmerman, Kirk M. Stueve, Charles H. Perry, Landscape-scale modeling of water quality in Lake Superior and Lake Michigan watersheds: How useful are forest-based indicators?, Journal of Great Lakes Research, 10.1016/j.jglr.2013.03.012, 39, 2, (211-223), (2013).
- Scott D. Cooper, P. Sam Lake, Sergi Sabater, John M. Melack, John L. Sabo, The effects of land use changes on streams and rivers in mediterranean climates, Hydrobiologia, 10.1007/s10750-012-1333-4, 719, 1, (383-425), (2012).
- Tao Zhang, Xiaojun Yang, Predicting Nitrogen Loading With Land-Cover Composition: How Can Watershed Size Affect Model Performance?, Environmental Management, 10.1007/s00267-012-9897-3, 51, 1, (96-107), (2012).
- W.L. Hadwen, P.I. Boon, A.H. Arthington, Not for all seasons: why timing is critical in the design of visitor impact monitoring programs for aquatic sites within protected areas, Australasian Journal of Environmental Management, 10.1080/14486563.2012.721225, 19, 4, (241-254), (2012).
