The price of protein: combining evolutionary and economic analysis to understand excessive energy consumption
Summary
Excessive weight gain appears, thermodynamically at least, straightforward: growing energy intake and/or falling energy expenditure create an energetic surplus, resulting in fat accumulation. The situation is, however, far more complex, with genetic, physiological, social, psychological and economic factors all implicated. Thus the causes of excessive weight gain remain difficult to disentangle. We combine two recent developments from different areas of nutrition research: the study of food prices in relation to energy content and the hypothesis that an evolved propensity to regulate protein intake more strongly than non‐protein calories exerts powerful leverage on overall energy intake. We partition the energy content of a range of common supermarket foods, and show that increasing overall energy content only modestly raises the cost of foods, largely as a result of macronutrients having very different costs. Higher food prices are associated with higher protein content and lower carbohydrate content, whereas fat content was not significantly associated with food price. We show that the differential costs of energy from protein and carbohydrates may bias consumers towards diets high in carbohydrate energy, leading them to consume excessive energy to meet their dietary protein needs. We review evidence from physiology, evolution and economics that support our suggestion.
Citing Literature
Number of times cited: 31
- Euridice Martínez Steele, David Raubenheimer, Stephen J Simpson, Larissa Galastri Baraldi and Carlos A Monteiro, Ultra-processed foods, protein leverage and energy intake in the USA, Public Health Nutrition, 21, 01, (114), (2018).
- Sean C. P. Coogan, David Raubenheimer, Simon P. Zantis and Gabriel E. Machovsky‐Capuska, Multidimensional nutritional ecology and urban birds, Ecosphere, 9, 4, (2018).
- Juan B. Ochoa Gautier, Robert G. Martindale, Saúl J. Rugeles, Ryan T. Hurt, Beth Taylor, Daren K. Heyland and Stephen A. McClave, How Much and What Type of Protein Should a Critically Ill Patient Receive?, Nutrition in Clinical Practice, 32, 1S, (6S-14S), (2017).
- Hayley G. Janssen, Ian G. Davies, Lucinda D. Richardson and Leonard Stevenson, Determinants of takeaway and fast food consumption: a narrative review, Nutrition Research Reviews, (1), (2017).
- Rosilene V. Ribeiro, Vasant Hirani, Alistair M. Senior, Alison K. Gosby, Robert G. Cumming, Fiona M. Blyth, Vasi Naganathan, Louise M. Waite, David J. Handelsman, Hal Kendig, Markus J. Seibel, Stephen J. Simpson, Fiona Stanaway, Margaret Allman-Farinelli and David G. Le Couteur, Diet quality and its implications on the cardio-metabolic, physical and general health of older men: the Concord Health and Ageing in Men Project (CHAMP), British Journal of Nutrition, 118, 02, (130), (2017).
- Michael W Schwartz, Randy J Seeley, Lori M Zeltser, Adam Drewnowski, Eric Ravussin, Leanne M Redman and Rudolph L Leibel, Obesity Pathogenesis: An Endocrine Society Scientific Statement, Endocrine Reviews, 38, 4, (267), (2017).
- Yonatan Wexler and Inon Scharf, Distinct effects of two separately applied stressors on behavior in the red flour beetle, Behavioural Processes, 145, (86), (2017).
- Thomas P Wycherley, Brita AK Pekarsky, Megan M Ferguson, Kerin O’Dea and Julie K Brimblecombe, Fluctuations in money availability within an income cycle impacts diet quality of remote Indigenous Australians, Public Health Nutrition, 20, 08, (1431), (2017).
- Traci A. Bekelman, Carolina Santamaría‐Ulloa, Darna L. Dufour, Lilliam Marín‐Arias and Ana Laura Dengo, Using the protein leverage hypothesis to understand socioeconomic variation in obesity, American Journal of Human Biology, 29, 3, (2017).
- Jason Collins, Boris Baer and Ernst Juerg Weber, Evolutionary Biology in Economics: A Review, Economic Record, 92, 297, (291-312), (2016).
- David Raubenheimer and Stephen J. Simpson, Nutritional Ecology and Human Health, Annual Review of Nutrition, 36, 1, (603), (2016).
- Claudia P. Campbell, David Raubenheimer, Asha V. Badaloo, Peter D. Gluckman, Claudia Martinez, Alison Gosby, Stephen J. Simpson, Clive Osmond, Michael S. Boyne and Terrence E. Forrester, Developmental contributions to macronutrient selection: a randomized controlled trial in adult survivors of malnutrition, Evolution, Medicine, and Public Health, 2016, 1, (158), (2016).
- Sean C. P. Coogan and David Raubenheimer, Might macronutrient requirements influence grizzly bear–human conflict? Insights from nutritional geometry, Ecosphere, 7, 1, (2016).
- Sonia Vega-López, Giselle Pignotti, Michael Todd and Colleen Keller, Egg Intake and Dietary Quality among Overweight and Obese Mexican-American Postpartum Women, Nutrients, 7, 12, (8402), (2015).
- Arianne J. Cease, Krista A. Capps, Kiza K. Gates, Michelle L. McCrackin and Daniel A. Nidzgorski, Consumer‐driven nutrient dynamics in urban environments: the stoichiometry of human diets and waste management, Oikos, 124, 7, (931-948), (2015).
- Karen L. Birkenhead and Gary Slater, A Review of Factors Influencing Athletes’ Food Choices, Sports Medicine, 45, 11, (1511), (2015).
- David Raubenheimer, Gabriel E. Machovsky-Capuska, Alison K. Gosby and Stephen Simpson, Nutritional ecology of obesity: from humans to companion animals, British Journal of Nutrition, 113, S1, (S26), (2015).
- Seema Patel, Functional food relevance of whey protein: A review of recent findings and scopes ahead, Journal of Functional Foods, 19, (308), (2015).
- George C Davis and Andrea Carlson, The inverse relationship between food price and energy density: is it spurious?, Public Health Nutrition, 18, 06, (1091), (2015).
- A. K. Gosby, A. D. Conigrave, D. Raubenheimer and S. J. Simpson, Protein leverage and energy intake, Obesity Reviews, 15, 3, (183-191), (2013).
- David Raubenheimer, Jessica M. Rothman, Herman Pontzer and Stephen J. Simpson, Macronutrient contributions of insects to the diets of hunter–gatherers: A geometric analysis, Journal of Human Evolution, 71, (70), (2014).
- Jeongju Kim and Donggyo Shin, Effects of Price Inflation Policy on Obesity: Focused on Sugar Sweetened Beverages, The Korean Journal of Obesity, 10.7570/kjo.2014.23.4.257, 23, 4, (257), (2014).
- B. L. Heitmann, K. R. Westerterp, R. J. F. Loos, T. I. A. Sørensen, K. O'Dea, P. McLean, T. K. Jensen, J. Eisenmann, J. R. Speakman, S. J. Simpson, D. R. Reed and M. S. Westerterp‐Plantenga, Obesity: lessons from evolution and the environment, Obesity Reviews, 13, 10, (910-922), (2012).
- Christopher D. Morrison, Scott D. Reed and Tara M. Henagan, Homeostatic regulation of protein intake: in search of a mechanism, American Journal of Physiology-Regulatory, Integrative and Comparative Physiology, 302, 8, (R917), (2012).
- M. N. Purpera, L. Shen, M. Taghavi, H. Munzberg, R. J. Martin, S. M. Hutson and C. D. Morrison, Impaired branched chain amino acid metabolism alters feeding behavior and increases orexigenic neuropeptide expression in the hypothalamus, Journal of Endocrinology, 212, 1, (85), (2012).
- Hans-Rudolf Berthoud, Heike Münzberg, Brenda K. Richards and Christopher D. Morrison, Neural and metabolic regulation of macronutrient intake and selection, Proceedings of the Nutrition Society, 71, 03, (390), (2012).
- Daniel J. Hruschka, Do economic constraints on food choice make people fat? A critical review of two hypotheses for the poverty-obesity paradox, American Journal of Human Biology, 24, 3, (277), (2012).
- Claudia Martinez-Cordero, Christopher W. Kuzawa, Deborah M. Sloboda, Joanna Stewart, Stephen J. Simpson and David Raubenheimer, Testing the Protein Leverage Hypothesis in a free-living human population, Appetite, 59, 2, (312), (2012).
- Shawn M. Wilder, Spider Nutrition, Spider Physiology and Behaviour - Physiology, 10.1016/B978-0-12-387668-3.00002-7, (87-136), (2011).
- Matthew Metzgar, Todd C. Rideout, Maelan Fontes-Villalba and Remko S. Kuipers, The feasibility of a Paleolithic diet for low-income consumers, Nutrition Research, 31, 6, (444), (2011).
- Robert Brooks, Alexei Maklakov and Daniel J. Rankin, Sex Differences in Obesity Associated with Total Fertility Rate, PLoS ONE, 5, 5, (e10587), (2010).
