Mitochondrial DNA Phylogeography of the North American Brown Bear and Implications for Conservation
Abstract
The historical distribution of the brown bear (Ursus arctos) in North America included Alaska, western Canada, the western and midwestern states, plus northern Mexico. Currently, the brown bear is limited to Alaska, the Canadian provinces of the Yukon, Northwest Territories, British Columbia, and Alberta, and six threatened subpopulations in the lower 48 states. To examine the evolutionary history of U. arctos in North America and to assess the genetic divergence between individuals from different geographic regions, we obtained 294 nucleotides of mitochondrial DNA sequence data from the control region for 317 free‐ranging brown bears. Twenty‐eight unique sequences, or mitochondrial DNA haplotypes were detected. The average sequence divergence between haplotypes was high (4.3%), and some haplotypes differed by as many as 23 nucleotides. Phylogenetic analyses using maximum parsimony revealed four major mitochondrial DNA phylogeographic groups, or clades. The significant phylogeographic structure detected in brown bears strongly contrasts with results obtained for other large carnivores and suggests limited female‐mediated gene flow. The mitochondrial DNA phylogeographic clades do not correlate with taxonomic classifications for U. arctos, and we hypothesize that the clades were formed prior to migration of this species into North America. We suggest evolutionarily significant units for conservation in three geographic regions: (1) the Alaskan islands of Admiralty, Baranof, and Chichagof; (2) mainland Alaska, Kodiak Island, and northern Canada; and (3) southern British Columbia, southern Alberta, and the states of Idaho, Montana, and Wyoming.
Filogenia del ADN Mitocondrial del Oso Café de Norte América y sus Implicaciones en la Conservación
La distribución histórica del oso café (Ursus arctos) en Norte Améica includía Alaska, oeste de Canada, oeste y medio oeste de los Estados Unidos y Norte de México. Actualmete, el oso café esta limitado a Alaska, las provincias Canadienses de Yukon, Northwest territories, British Columbia, Alberta y seis subpoblaciones amenazadas en 48 estados de los Estados Unidos. Obtuvimos datos de secuencias de 294 nucleótidos de ADN mitocondrial de la región control de 317 osos cafes para examinar la historia evolutiva de U. arctos en Norte América y evaluar la divergencia genética entre individuos de diferentes regiones geográficas. Fueron detectadas veintiocho secuencias únicas o haplotipos de ADN mitocondrial. El porcentaje de secuencia divergente entre haplotipos fue alto (4.3%) y algunos haplotipos difirieron por tantos como 23 nucleótidos. Análisis filogenéticos usando maxima parsimonia revelaron cuatro grupos mayores de ADN mitocondrial filogeográfico. La estructura filogeografica significativa detectada en osos cafés contrasta fuertemente con resultados obtenidos de otros carnivoros mayores y sugiere flujo genético limitado, mediado por las hembras. Los grupos de ADN mitocondrial filogeográfico no se correlacionan con clasificaciones taxonómicas de U. arctos, nosotros hipotetizamos que los grupos fueron formados antes de las migraciones de esta especie hacia Norte América. Sugerimos unidades evolutivamente significativas para su conservación en tres regiones geográficas: 1) las islas Admiralty, Baranof y Chichagof de Alaska; 2) el territorio continential de Alaska, la isla Kodiak y el norte de Canada, y 3) Sur de British Columbia, sur de Alberta y los estados de Idaho, Montana y Wyoming en los Estados Unidos.
Number of times cited: 28
- Peeter Anijalg, Simon Y. W. Ho, John Davison, Marju Keis, Egle Tammeleht, Katalina Bobowik, Igor L. Tumanov, Alexander P. Saveljev, Elena A. Lyapunova, Alexandr A. Vorobiev, Nikolai I. Markov, Alexey P. Kryukov, Ilpo Kojola, Jon E. Swenson, Snorre B. Hagen, Hans Geir Eiken, Ladislav Paule and Urmas Saarma, Large‐scale migrations of brown bears in Eurasia and to North America during the Late Pleistocene, Journal of Biogeography, 45, 2, (394-405), (2017).
- Carlo Meloro, Giulia Guidarelli, Paolo Colangelo, Paolo Ciucci and Anna Loy, Mandible size and shape in extant Ursidae (Carnivora, Mammalia): A tool for taxonomy and ecogeography, Journal of Zoological Systematics and Evolutionary Research, 55, 4, (269-287), (2017).
- James R. Heffelfinger, Ronald M. Nowak and David Paetkau, Clarifying historical range to aid recovery of the Mexican wolf, The Journal of Wildlife Management, 81, 5, (766-777), (2017).
- F. Gözde Çilingir, Çiğdem Akın Pekşen, Hüseyin Ambarlı, Peter Beerli and C. Can Bilgin, Exceptional maternal lineage diversity in brown bears (rsus arctos) from Turkey, Zoological Journal of the Linnean Society, 176, 2, (463-477), (2015).
- James A. Cahill, Ian Stirling, Logan Kistler, Rauf Salamzade, Erik Ersmark, Tara L. Fulton, Mathias Stiller, Richard E. Green and Beth Shapiro, Genomic evidence of geographically widespread effect of gene flow from polar bears into brown bears, Molecular Ecology, 24, 6, (1205-1217), (2015).
- Sarah C.E. Bray, Jeremy J. Austin, Jessica L. Metcalf, Kjartan Østbye, Eivind Østbye, Stein‐Erik Lauritzen, Kim Aaris‐Sørensen, Cristina Valdiosera, Christina J Adler and Alan Cooper, Ancient DNA identifies post‐glacial recolonisation, not recent bottlenecks, as the primary driver of contemporary mtDNA phylogeography and diversity in Scandinavian brown bears, Diversity and Distributions, 19, 3, (245-256), (2012).
- Di Yan Li, Huai Liang Xu, David Glenn Smith, An Chun Cheng, Jessica Satkoski Trask, Qing Zhu, Yong Fang Yao, Dan Dan Du and Qing Yong Ni, Phylogenetic analysis of chinese rhesus macaques (Macaca mulatta) based on mitochondrial control region sequences, American Journal of Primatology, 73, 9, (883-895), (2011).
- Jolene Scoble and Andrew John Lowe, A case for incorporating phylogeography and landscape genetics into species distribution modelling approaches to improve climate adaptation and conservation planning, Diversity and Distributions, 16, 3, (343-353), (2010).
- Sébastien Calvignac, Sandrine Hughes and Catherine Hänni, Genetic diversity of endangered brown bear (Ursus arctos) populations at the crossroads of Europe, Asia and Africa, Diversity and Distributions, 15, 5, (742-750), (2009).
- UMA RAMAKRISHNAN and ELIZABETH A. HADLY, Using phylochronology to reveal cryptic population histories: review and synthesis of 29 ancient DNA studies, Molecular Ecology, 18, 7, (1310-1330), (2009).
- MARJU KORSTEN, SIMON Y. W. HO, JOHN DAVISON, BERIT PÄHN, EGLE VULLA, MARIS ROHT, IGOR L. TUMANOV, ILPO KOJOLA, ZANETE ANDERSONE‐LILLEY, JANIS OZOLINS, MALGORZATA PILOT, YORGOS MERTZANIS, ALEXIOS GIANNAKOPOULOS, ALEX A. VOROBIEV, NIKOLAI I. MARKOV, ALEXANDER P. SAVELJEV, ELENA A. LYAPUNOVA, ALEXEI V. ABRAMOV, PEEP MÄNNIL, HARRI VALDMANN, SERGEI V. PAZETNOV, VALENTIN S. PAZETNOV, ALEXANDER M. RÕKOV and URMAS SAARMA, Sudden expansion of a single brown bear maternal lineage across northern continental Eurasia after the last ice age: a general demographic model for mammals?, Molecular Ecology, 18, 9, (1963-1979), (2009).
- THUY T. T. NGUYEN, Population structure in the highly fragmented range of Tor douronensis (Cyprinidae) in Sarawak, Malaysia revealed by microsatellite DNA markers, Freshwater Biology, 53, 5, (924-934), (2008).
- SEBASTIEN CALVIGNAC, SANDRINE HUGHES, CHRISTELLE TOUGARD, JACQUES MICHAUX, MICHEL THEVENOT, MICHEL PHILIPPE, WATIK HAMDINE and CATHERINE HÄNNI, Ancient DNA evidence for the loss of a highly divergent brown bear clade during historical times, Molecular Ecology, 17, 8, (1962-1970), (2008).
- URMAS SAARMA, SIMON Y. W. HO, OLIVER G. PYBUS, MARJU KALJUSTE, IGOR L. TUMANOV, ILPO. KOJOLA, ALEX A. VOROBIEV, NIKOLAI I. MARKOV, ALEXANDER P. SAVELJEV, HARRI VALDMANN, ELENA A. LYAPUNOVA, ALEXEI V. ABRAMOV, PEEP. MÄNNIL, MARJU KORSTEN, EGLE. VULLA, SERGEI V. PAZETNOV, VALENTIN S. PAZETNOV, STANISLAV V. PUTCHKOVSKIY and ALEXANDER M. RÕKOV, Mitogenetic structure of brown bears (Ursus arctos L.) in northeastern Europe and a new time frame for the formation of European brown bear lineages, Molecular Ecology, 16, 2, (401-413), (2006).
- P. Christiansen, Evolutionary implications of bite mechanics and feeding ecology in bears, Journal of Zoology, 272, 4, (423-443), (2007).
- MATTHEW A. CRONIN, A Proposal to Eliminate Redundant Terminology for Intra‐Species Groups, Wildlife Society Bulletin, 34, 1, (237-241), (2010).
- C. R. MILLER, L. P. WAITS and P. JOYCE, Phylogeography and mitochondrial diversity of extirpated brown bear (Ursus arctos) populations in the contiguous United States and Mexico, Molecular Ecology, 15, 14, (4477-4485), (2006).
- BYRON V. WECKWORTH, SANDRA TALBOT, GEORGE K. SAGE, DAVID K. PERSON and JOSEPH COOK, A Signal for Independent Coastal and Continental histories among North American wolves, Molecular Ecology, 14, 4, (917-931), (2005).
- J. R. MICHAUX, O. J. HARDY, F. JUSTY, P. FOURNIER, A. KRANZ, M. CABRIA, A. DAVISON, R. ROSOUX and R. LIBOIS, Conservation genetics and population history of the threatened European mink Mustela lutreola, with an emphasis on the west European population, Molecular Ecology, 14, 8, (2373-2388), (2005).
- Robert K. Wayne and Phillip A. Morin, Conservation genetics in the new molecular age, Frontiers in Ecology and the Environment, 2, 2, (89-97), (2004).
- C. C. Cegelski, L. P. Waits and N. J. Anderson, Assessing population structure and gene flow in Montana wolverines (Gulo gulo) using assignment‐based approaches, Molecular Ecology, 12, 11, (2907-2918), (2003).
- R. E. Drew, J. G. Hallett, K. B. Aubry, K. W. Cullings, S. M. Koepf and W. J. Zielinski, Conservation genetics of the fisher (Martes pennanti) based on mitochondrial DNA sequencing, Molecular Ecology, 12, 1, (51-62), (2002).
- José Alexandre Felizola Diniz‐Filho and Mariana Pires De Campos Telles, Spatial Autocorrelation Analysis and the Identification of Operational Units for Conservation in Continuous Populations, Conservation Biology, 16, 4, (924-935), (2002).
- Marilyn Nielson, Kirk Lohman and Jack Sullivan, PHYLOGEOGRAPHY OF THE TAILED FROG (ASCAPHUS TRUEI): IMPLICATIONS FOR THE BIOGEOGRAPHY OF THE PACIFIC NORTHWEST, Evolution, 55, 1, (147-160), (2007).
- Robert L. Hammond, William Macasero, Benito Flores, Osama B. Mohammed, Tim Wacher and Michael W. Bruford, Phylogenetic Reanalysis of the Saudi Gazelle and Its Implications for Conservation, Conservation Biology, 15, 4, (1123-1133), (2002).
- C. Vilà, I. R. Amorim, J. A. Leonard, D. Posada, J. Castroviejo, F. Petrucci‐Fonseca, K. A. Crandall, H. Ellegren and R. K. Wayne, Mitochondrial DNA phylogeography and population history of the grey wolf Canis lupus, Molecular Ecology, 8, 12, (2089-2103), (2002).
- K. Holder, R. Montgomerie and V. L. Friesen, A TEST OF THE GLACIAL REFUGIUM HYPOTHESIS USING PATTERNS OF MITOCHONDRIAL AND NUCLEAR DNA SEQUENCE VARIATION IN ROCK PTARMIGAN (LAGOPUS MUTUS), Evolution, 53, 6, (1936-1950), (2017).
- James M. Grady and Joseph M. Quattro, Using Character Concordance to Define Taxonomic and Conservation Units, Conservation Biology, 13, 5, (1004-1007), (2001).




