Reexamining the Case for Marriage: Union Formation and Changes in Well‐being
Center for Demography and Ecology, University of Wisconsin–Madison, 4412 Sewell Social Sciences Building, 1180 Observatory Drive, Madison, WI 53706‐1393.
Abstract
This article addresses open questions about the nature and meaning of the positive association between marriage and well‐being, namely, the extent to which it is causal, shared with cohabitation, and stable over time. We relied on data from the National Survey of Families and Households (N = 2,737) and a modeling approach that controls for fixed differences between individuals by relating union transitions to changes in well‐being. This study is unique in examining the persistence of changes in well‐being as marriages and cohabitations progress (and potentially dissolve) over time. The effects of marriage and cohabitation are found to be similar across a range of measures tapping psychological well‐being, health, and social ties. Where there are statistically significant differences, marriage is not always more advantageous. Overall, differences tend to be small and appear to dissipate over time, even when the greater instability of cohabitation is taken into account.
Citing Literature
Number of times cited: 88
- Dmitry Tumin and Hui Zheng, Do the Health Benefits of Marriage Depend on the Likelihood of Marriage?, Journal of Marriage and Family, 80, 3, (622-636), (2018).
- Dmitry Tumin, Does Marriage Protect Health? A Birth Cohort Comparison*, Social Science Quarterly, 99, 2, (626-643), (2017).
- Malgorzata Switek and Richard A. Easterlin, Life Transitions and Life Satisfaction During Young Adulthood, Journal of Happiness Studies, 19, 1, (297), (2018).
- Karen van Hedel, Pekka Martikainen, Heta Moustgaard and Mikko Myrskylä, Cohabitation and mental health: Is cohabiting as good for your mental health as marriage?, SSM - Population Health, (2018).
- Brandy Renee McCann and Katherine R. Allen, Romantic Forecasts in Later Life: Older Single Women’s Perspectives on Family and Kin Relationships, Journal of Family Issues, 39, 3, (747), (2018).
- Brienna Perelli‐Harris and Marta Styrc, Mental Well‐Being Differences in Cohabitation and Marriage: The Role of Childhood Selection, Journal of Marriage and Family, 80, 1, (239-255), (2017).
- Elena Pirani, Do Italians still contact their mother? Several differences by type of union, Journal of Family Studies, (1), (2018).
- CLAUDIA CHLOE BRUMBAUGH, Transferring connections: Friend and sibling attachments' importance in the lives of singles, Personal Relationships, 24, 3, (534-549), (2017).
- Camilla J. Hodge, Mat D. Duerden, Eric K. Layland, Andrew Lacanienta, Michael C. Goates and Xiaoyue Maggie Niu, The Association Between Family Leisure and Family Quality of Life: A Meta‐Analysis of Data from Parents and Adolescents, Journal of Family Theory & Review, 9, 3, (328-346), (2017).
- Benjamin T. Gurrentz, Family Formation and Close Social Ties Within Religious Congregations, Journal of Marriage and Family, 79, 4, (1125-1143), (2017).
- Kenneth Aarskaug Wiik and Eva Bernhardt, Cohabiting and Married Individuals' Relations With Their Partner's Parents, Journal of Marriage and Family, 79, 4, (1111-1124), (2017).
- Julie Skalamera Olson and Robert Crosnoe, Are You Still Bringing Me Down?, Journal of Health and Social Behavior, 58, 1, (102), (2017).
- Heather R. Kennedy, Rochelle L. Dalla and Steven Dreesman, “We are Two of the Lucky Ones”: Experiences with Marriage and Wellbeing for Same-Sex Couples, Journal of Homosexuality, (1), (2017).
- Lisa Strohschein and Usha Ram, Gender, Marital Status, and Mental Health: A Test of the Sex Role Hypothesis in India, Journal of Family Issues, 38, 13, (1899), (2017).
- Lindy Williams, Renling Zhang and Kevin C. Packard, Factors affecting the physical and mental health of older adults in China: The importance of marital status, child proximity, and gender, SSM - Population Health, 3, (20), (2017).
- Sara Zella, Marital Status Transitions and Self-Reported Health among Canadians: A Life Course Perspective, Applied Research in Quality of Life, 12, 2, (303), (2017).
- Maudry-Beverley Lashley, Vanessa Marshall and TyWanda McLaurin-Jones, African American Women Seeking Strength in Romance and Family Relationships, Family Dynamics and Romantic Relationships in a Changing Society, 10.4018/978-1-5225-2404-5.ch010, (193-211)
- Jay Fagan, Income and Cognitive Stimulation as Moderators of the Association Between Family Structure and Preschoolers’ Emerging Literacy and Math, Journal of Family Issues, 10.1177/0192513X16640018, 38, 17, (2400-2424), (2016).
- Matthijs Kalmijn, The Ambiguous Link between Marriage and Health: A Dynamic Reanalysis of Loss and Gain Effects, Social Forces, 95, 4, (1607), (2017).
- Rena C. Zito, Relative Employment, Gender Beliefs, and Intimate Partner Coercion and Violence Against New Mothers Across Marital and Residential Contexts, Journal of Interpersonal Violence, (088626051771560), (2017).
- Patricia A Thomas, Hui Liu, Debra Umberson and J Jill Suitor, Family Relationships and Well-Being, Innovation in Aging, 1, 3, (2017).
- Sara E. Mernitz, The Mental Health Implications of Emerging Adult Long-Term Cohabitation, Emerging Adulthood, (216769681773391), (2017).
- Susan L. Brown, Wendy D. Manning and Krista K. Payne, Relationship Quality Among Cohabiting Versus Married Couples, Journal of Family Issues, 38, 12, (1730), (2017).
- Alfred DeMaris, Marriage Advantage in Subjective Well-Being: Causal Effect or Unmeasured Heterogeneity?, Marriage & Family Review, (1), (2017).
- Marcia J. Carlson and Alicia G. VanOrman, Trajectories of relationship supportiveness after childbirth: Does marriage matter?, Social Science Research, 66, (102), (2017).
- Sojung Lim and James M. Raymo, Marriage and Women's Health in Japan, Journal of Marriage and Family, 78, 3, (780-796), (2016).
- Elena Pirani and Daniele Vignoli, Changes in the Satisfaction of Cohabitors Relative to Spouses Over Time, Journal of Marriage and Family, 78, 3, (598-609), (2016).
- Jacquelyn J. Benson and Marilyn Coleman, Older Adults Developing a Preference for Living Apart Together, Journal of Marriage and Family, 78, 3, (797-812), (2016).
- Jennifer E. Copp, Peggy C. Giordano, Monica A. Longmore and Wendy D. Manning, Dating violence and physical health: A longitudinal lens on the significance of relationship dynamics and anti‐social lifestyle characteristics, Criminal Behaviour and Mental Health, 26, 4, (251-262), (2016).
- B. DePaulo, Singles and Mental Health, Encyclopedia of Mental Health, 10.1016/B978-0-12-397045-9.00115-4, (158-165), (2016).
- Mieke Beth Thomeer, Stipica Mudrazija and Jacqueline L. Angel, Relationship Status and Long-Term Care Facility Use in Later Life, The Journals of Gerontology Series B: Psychological Sciences and Social Sciences, 71, 4, (711), (2016).
- Morten Blekesaune, Is Cohabitation As Good As Marriage for People’s Subjective Well-Being? Longitudinal Evidence on Happiness and Life Satisfaction in the British Household Panel Survey, Journal of Happiness Studies, (2016).
- Vered Ben-David, Melissa Jonson-Reid, Charlotte Bright and Brett Drake, Family formation: A positive outcome for vulnerable young women?, Children and Youth Services Review, 67, (57), (2016).
- Glenn Deane, Glenna Spitze, Russell A. Ward and Yue (Angela) Zhuo, Close To You? How Parent–Adult Child Contact Is Influenced by Family Patterns, The Journals of Gerontology Series B: Psychological Sciences and Social Sciences, 71, 2, (344), (2016).
- Dimiter Philipov and Sergei Scherbov, Differences by union status in health and mortality at older ages: Results for 16 European countries, Demographic Research, 35, (535), (2016).
- Anna M. Hammersmith and I-Fen Lin, Evaluative and Experienced Well-being of Caregivers of Parents and Caregivers of Children, The Journals of Gerontology Series B: Psychological Sciences and Social Sciences, (gbw065), (2016).
- Kelly Musick, Ann Meier and Sarah Flood, How Parents Fare, American Sociological Review, 81, 5, (1069), (2016).
- Thomas Leopold and Matthijs Kalmijn, Is Divorce More Painful When Couples Have Children? Evidence From Long-Term Panel Data on Multiple Domains of Well-being, Demography, 53, 6, (1717), (2016).
- K.J. August, C.S. Kelly and C.N. Markey, Marriage, Romantic Relationships, and Health, Encyclopedia of Mental Health, 10.1016/B978-0-12-397045-9.00074-4, (46-52), (2016).
- Yuthika U. Girme, Nickola C. Overall, Sivailele Faingataa and Chris G. Sibley, Happily Single, Social Psychological and Personality Science, 7, 2, (122), (2016).
- Celia C. Lo, Tyrone C. Cheng and Gaynell M. Simpson, Marital status and work-related health limitation: a longitudinal study of young adult and middle-aged Americans, International Journal of Public Health, 61, 1, (91), (2016).
- Kenneth Aarskaug Wiik and Eva Bernhardt, Gendered expectations: expected consequences of union formation across Europe, Journal of Family Studies, (1), (2016).
- Stephanie Y Davis, Jonathan G Sandberg, Angela B Bradford and Jeffry H Larson, Gender differences in couple attachment behaviors as predictors of dietary habits and physical activity levels, Journal of Health Psychology, 21, 12, (3048), (2016).
- Claudia Masferrer, Does family matter for recent immigrants’ life satisfaction?, Advances in Life Course Research, 30, (53), (2016).
- Kevin D. Dougherty, Brandon C. Martinez and Gerardo Martí, Congregational Diversity and Attendance in a Mainline Protestant Denomination, Journal for the Scientific Study of Religion, 54, 4, (668-683), (2016).
- Olga Stavrova and Detlef Fetchenhauer, Married and cohabiting parents’ well-being, Journal of Social and Personal Relationships, 32, 5, (601), (2015).
- Brian J. Willoughby, BreeAnne Madsen, Jason S. Carroll and Dean M. Busby, “Want to Stay Over?” Demographic, Intrapersonal, and Relational Differences Among Those Who Date, Stay-Over, and Cohabit, Marriage & Family Review, 51, 7, (587), (2015).
- Jutta Mata, Ronald Frank and Ralph Hertwig, Higher body mass index, less exercise, but healthier eating in married adults: Nine representative surveys across Europe, Social Science & Medicine, 138, (119), (2015).
- Theo G. van Tilburg, Marja J. Aartsen and Suzan van der Pas, Loneliness after Divorce: A Cohort Comparison among Dutch Young-Old Adults, European Sociological Review, 31, 3, (243), (2015).
- Shoshana Grossbard, Introduction, The Marriage Motive: A Price Theory of Marriage, 10.1007/978-1-4614-1623-4_1, (1-18), (2014).
- Geneviève Bouchard and Jean Saint-Aubin, Executive control of married and cohabiting couples, Personality and Individual Differences, 78, (58), (2015).
- A. Hiyoshi, K. Fall, G. Netuveli and S. Montgomery, Remarriage after divorce and depression risk, Social Science & Medicine, 141, (109), (2015).
- Alicia N. Rubel and Anthony F. Bogaert, Consensual Nonmonogamy: Psychological Well-Being and Relationship Quality Correlates, The Journal of Sex Research, 52, 9, (961), (2015).
- James R. Fleckenstein and Derrell W. Cox, The association of an open relationship orientation with health and happiness in a sample of older US adults, Sexual and Relationship Therapy, 30, 1, (94), (2015).
- Sara Symoens and Piet Bracke, Work-family conflict and mental health in newlywed and recently cohabiting couples: a couple perspective, Health Sociology Review, 24, 1, (48), (2015).
- Feinian Chen, Hui Liu, Kriti Vikram and Yu Guo, For Better or Worse: The Health Implications of Marriage Separation Due to Migration in Rural China, Demography, 52, 4, (1321), (2015).
- Sara Symoens, Elien Colman and Piet Bracke, Divorce, conflict, and mental health: how the quality of intimate relationships is linked to post‐divorce well‐being, Journal of Applied Social Psychology, 44, 3, (220-233), (2014).
- Deborah Carr, Kristen W. Springer and Kristi Williams, Health and Families, The Wiley Blackwell Companion to the Sociology of Families, (255-276), (2014).
- Corinne Reczek, Hui Liu and Russell Spiker, A Population‐Based Study of Alcohol Use in Same‐Sex and Different‐Sex Unions, Journal of Marriage and Family, 76, 3, (557-572), (2014).
- Judith Treas, Jonathan Lui and Zoya Gubernskaya, Children’s union status and contact with mothers, Demographic Research, 30, (1495), (2014).
- Jennifer L. Kohn and Susan L. Averett, Can’t We Just Live Together? New Evidence on the Effect of Relationship Status on Health, Journal of Family and Economic Issues, 35, 3, (295), (2014).
- Sonja E. Siennick, Jeremy Staff, D. Wayne Osgood, John E. Schulenberg, Jerald G. Bachman and Matthew VanEseltine, Partnership Transitions and Antisocial Behavior in Young Adulthood, Journal of Research in Crime and Delinquency, 51, 6, (735), (2014).
- Rhiannon A. Kroeger and Pamela J. Smock, Cohabitation, The Wiley Blackwell Companion to the Sociology of Families, (217-235), (2014).
- Jennifer L. Kohn and Susan L. Averett, The effect of relationship status on health with dynamic health and persistent relationships, Journal of Health Economics, 36, (69), (2014).
- Niina Metsä-Simola and Pekka Martikainen, The effects of marriage and separation on the psychotropic medication use of non-married cohabiters: A register-based longitudinal study among adult Finns, Social Science & Medicine, 121, (10), (2014).
- Jenjira Yahirun and Dana Hamplová, Children’s union status and contact with mothers: A cross-national study, Demographic Research, 30, (1413), (2014).
- Russell Ward, Glenn Deane and Glenna Spitze, Life-Course Changes and Parent–Adult Child Contact, Research on Aging, 36, 5, (568), (2014).
- Bella DePaulo, A Singles Studies Perspective on Mount Marriage, Psychological Inquiry, 25, 1, (64), (2014).
- Andrew Bell, Life-course and cohort trajectories of mental health in the UK, 1991–2008 – A multilevel age–period–cohort analysis, Social Science & Medicine, 120, (21), (2014).
- April S. Masarik, Rand D. Conger, Monica J. Martin, M. Brent Donnellan, Katherine E. Masyn and Frederick O. Lorenz, Romantic relationships in early adulthood: Influences of family, personality, and relationship cognitions, Personal Relationships, 20, 2, (356-373), (2012).
- Angela Abela and Janet Walker, Global Changes in Marriage, Parenting and Family Life, Contemporary Issues in Family Studies, (5-15), (2013).
- Jan Pryor, Marriage and Divorce in the Western World, Contemporary Issues in Family Studies, (46-58), (2013).
- Timothy A. Ortyl, Long‐Term Heterosexual Cohabiters and Attitudes toward Marriage, The Sociological Quarterly, 54, 4, (584-609), (2013).
- Bella DePaulo, Single in a Society Preoccupied with Couples, The Handbook of Solitude, (302-316), (2013).
- Eva-Maria Merz and Suzanne Jak, The long reach of childhood. Childhood experiences influence close relationships and loneliness across life, Advances in Life Course Research, 18, 3, (212), (2013).
- Charles Lanfear, Scott Akins and Clayton Mosher, Examining the Relationship of Substance Use and Sexual Orientation, Deviant Behavior, 34, 7, (586), (2013).
- E. E. Sutherland, From 'Bidie-in' to 'Cohabitant' in Scotland: The Perils of Legislative Compromise, International Journal of Law, Policy and the Family, 27, 2, (143), (2013).
- Hui Liu, Corinne Reczek and Dustin Brown, Same-Sex Cohabitors and Health, Journal of Health and Social Behavior, 54, 1, (25), (2013).
- Justin T. Denney, Bridget K. Gorman and Cristina B. Barrera, Families, Resources, and Adult Health, Journal of Health and Social Behavior, 54, 1, (46), (2013).
- Nevena Kulic, The type and duration of family unions and income sharing: The implications for women's economic well-being, The Journal of Socio-Economics, 44, (7), (2013).
- Huijun Liu, Shuzhuo Li and Marc W. Feldman, Gender in Marriage and Life Satisfaction Under Gender Imbalance in China: The Role of Intergenerational Support and SES, Social Indicators Research, 114, 3, (915), (2013).
- Ashley B. Barr, Elizabeth Culatta and Ronald L. Simons, Romantic Relationships and Health among African American Young Adults, Journal of Health and Social Behavior, 54, 3, (369), (2013).
- Hui Liu and Corinne Reczek, Cohabitation and U.S. Adult Mortality: An Examination by Gender and Race, Journal of Marriage and Family, 74, 4, (794-811), (2012).
- W. Justin Dyer, Joseph Pleck and Brent McBride, Using Mixture Regression to Identify Varying Effects: A Demonstration With Paternal Incarceration, Journal of Marriage and Family, 74, 5, (1129-1148), (2012).
- Sven E. Wilson, Marriage, gender and obesity in later life, Economics & Human Biology, 10.1016/j.ehb.2012.04.012, 10, 4, (431-453), (2012).
- Luke T. Russell, Marilyn Coleman and Lawrence Ganong, Conceptualizing Family Structure in a Social Determinants of Health Framework, Journal of Family Theory & Review, , (2018).
- Robert Joseph Taylor, Ivy Forsythe-Brown, Dawne M. Mouzon, Verna M. Keith, David H. Chae and Linda M. Chatters, Prevalence and correlates of everyday discrimination among black Caribbeans in the United States: the impact of nativity and country of origin, Ethnicity & Health, 10.1080/13557858.2017.1346785, (1-21), (2017).
- Scott L. Feld and Jordan A. Meyer, Evidence Required to Know Whether Marriage Promotion Increases Other Social Benefits, Journal of Family Theory & Review, , (2018).
