Male Homosexuality: Nature or Culture?
ABSTRACT
Introduction. Debate continues on whether or not male homosexuality (MH) is a result of biological or cultural factors. The debate persists despite the fact that these two sides have different abilities to create a scientific environment to support their cause. Biological theorists produced evidence, however, that these are not always robust. On the other hand, social theorists, without direct evidence confirming their positions, criticize, with good argument, methods and results of the other side. The aim of this Controversy is to understand the reasons of both perspectives.
Methods. Two scientists (R.B. and A.C.C.) with expertise in the area of biology of MH were asked to contribute their opinions. The nurture position is discussed by a third expert in sexology (J.B.).
Main Outcome Measure. Expert opinion supported by the critical review of the currently available literature.
Result. The role of the Controversy's editor (E.A.J.) is to highlight the strengths and weaknesses of both sides. The two experts of the biological issue answer with their data to the questions: “Is male homosexuality partly explainable by immunology?” and “How is male homosexuality a Darwinian paradox?”, respectively. Genetic and immunological factors, birth order, and fertility of relatives are largely discussed. Finally, the expert sustaining the idea that culture and experiences are important determining factors in sexual orientation used a psychosocial and holistic perspective to explain his position.
Conclusions. The JSM's readers should recognize that there are several biological factors in MH. However, these findings do not seem to be able to explain all cases of homosexuality. Some others may be due to particular environmental factors. The issue is complicated and multifactorial, suggesting that further research should be undertaken to produce the final answer to the question raised in this Controversy section. Jannini EA, Blanchard R, Camperio‐Ciani A, and Bancroft J. Male homosexuality: Nature or culture? J Sex Med 2010;7:3245–3253.
Number of times cited: 9
- Emmanuele A. Jannini, Andrea Burri, Patrick Jern and Giuseppe Novelli, Genetics of Human Sexual Behavior: Where We Are, Where We Are Going, Sexual Medicine Reviews, 3, 2, (65-77), (2015).
- Giacomo Ciocca, Nicolina Capuano, Bogdan Tuziak, Daniele Mollaioli, Erika Limoncin, Diana Valsecchi, Eleonora Carosa, Giovanni L. Gravina, Daniele Gianfrilli, Andrea Lenzi and Emmanuele A. Jannini, Italian Validation of Homophobia Scale (HS), Sexual Medicine, 3, 3, (213-218), (2015).
- Lee Ellis, Amy Lykins, Anthony Hoskin and Malini Ratnasingam, Putative Androgen Exposure and Sexual Orientation: Cross‐Cultural Evidence Suggesting a Modified Neurohormonal Theory, The Journal of Sexual Medicine, 12, 12, (2364-2377), (2015).
- Wei Yu, Dan Tu, Fuchang Hong, Jing Wang, Xiaoli Liu, Yumao Cai, Ruiwei Xu, Guanglu Zhao, Feng Wang, Hong Pan, Shinan Wu, Tiejian Feng and Binbin Wang, Analysis of the Association between Catechol‐O‐Methyltransferase Val158Met and Male Sexual Orientation, The Journal of Sexual Medicine, 12, 9, (1920-1926), (2015).
- Giacomo Ciocca, Bogdan Tuziak, Erika Limoncin, Daniele Mollaioli, Nicolina Capuano, Alessia Martini, Eleonora Carosa, Alessandra D. Fisher, Mario Maggi, Cinzia Niolu, Alberto Siracusano, Andrea Lenzi and Emmanuele A. Jannini, Psychoticism, Immature Defense Mechanisms and a Fearful Attachment Style are Associated with a Higher Homophobic Attitude, The Journal of Sexual Medicine, 12, 9, (1953-1960), (2015).
- Andrea Camperio Ciani and Umberto Battaglia, Implicit Measurements of Sexual Preference in Self‐Declared Heterosexual Men: A Pilot Study on the Rate of Androphilia in Italy, The Journal of Sexual Medicine, 11, 9, (2207-2217), (2014).
- Giacomo Ciocca, Erika Limoncin, Alessandro Cellerino, Alessandra D. Fisher, Giovanni Luca Gravina, Eleonora Carosa, Daniele Mollaioli, Dario R. Valenzano, Andrea Mennucci, Elisa Bandini, Savino M. Di Stasi, Mario Maggi, Andrea Lenzi and Emmanuele A. Jannini, Gender Identity Rather Than Sexual Orientation Impacts on Facial Preferences, The Journal of Sexual Medicine, 11, 10, (2500-2507), (2014).
- Andrea S. Camperio Ciani, Lilybeth Fontanesi, Francesca Iemmola, Elga Giannella, Claudia Ferron and Luigi Lombardi, Factors Associated with Higher Fecundity in Female Maternal Relatives of Homosexual Men, The Journal of Sexual Medicine, 9, 11, (2878-2887), (2012).
- Sabine Kagerer, Tim Klucken, Sina Wehrum, Mark Zimmermann, Anne Schienle, Bertram Walter, Dieter Vaitl and Rudolf Stark, Neural Activation Toward Erotic Stimuli in Homosexual and Heterosexual Males, The Journal of Sexual Medicine, 8, 11, (3132-3143), (2011).
