Matching species traits to projected threats and opportunities from climate change
Abstract
Aim
Climate change can lead to decreased climatic suitability within species' distributions, increased fragmentation of climatically suitable space, and/or emergence of newly suitable areas outside present distributions. Each of these extrinsic threats and opportunities potentially interacts with specific intrinsic traits of species, yet this specificity is seldom considered in risk assessments. We present an analytical framework for examining projections of climate change‐induced threats and opportunities with reference to traits that are likely to mediate species' responses, and illustrate the applicability of the framework.
Location
Sub‐Saharan Africa.
Methods
We applied the framework to 195 sub‐Saharan African amphibians with both available bioclimatic envelope model projections for the mid‐21st century and trait data. Excluded were 500 narrow‐ranging species mainly from montane areas. For each of projected losses, increased fragmentation and gains of climate space, we selected potential response‐mediating traits and examined the spatial overlap with vulnerability due to these traits. We examined the overlap for all species, and individually for groups of species with different combinations of threats and opportunities.
Results
In the Congo Basin and arid Southern Africa, projected losses for wide‐ranging amphibians were compounded by sensitivity to climatic variation, and expected gains were precluded by poor dispersal ability. The spatial overlap between exposure and vulnerability was more pronounced for species projected to have their climate space contracting in situ or shifting to distant geographical areas. Our results exclude the potential exposure of narrow‐ranging species to shrinking climates in the African tropical mountains.
Main conclusions
We illustrate the application of a framework combining spatial projections of climate change exposure with traits that are likely to mediate species' responses. Although the proposed framework carries several assumptions that require further scrutiny, its application adds a degree of realism to familiar assessments that consider all species to be equally affected by climate change‐induced threats and opportunities.
Citing Literature
Number of times cited according to CrossRef: 40
- Wendy B. Foden, Bruce E. Young, H. Resit Akçakaya, Raquel A. Garcia, Ary A. Hoffmann, Bruce A. Stein, Chris D. Thomas, Christopher J. Wheatley, David Bickford, Jamie A. Carr, David G. Hole, Tara G. Martin, Michela Pacifici, James W. Pearce‐Higgins, Philip J. Platts, Piero Visconti, James E. M. Watson and Brian Huntley, Climate change vulnerability assessment of species, Wiley Interdisciplinary Reviews: Climate Change, 10, 1, (2018).
- Justin G. Schuetz, Katherine E. Mills, Andrew J. Allyn, Karen Stamieszkin, Arnault Le Bris and Andrew J. Pershing, Complex patterns of temperature sensitivity, not ecological traits, dictate diverse species responses to climate change, Ecography, 42, 1, (111-124), (2018).
- I. Aubin, L. Boisvert‐Marsh, H. Kebli, D. McKenney, J. Pedlar, K. Lawrence, E. H. Hogg, Y. Boulanger, S. Gauthier and C. Ste‐Marie, Tree vulnerability to climate change: improving exposure‐based assessments using traits as indicators of sensitivity, Ecosphere, 9, 2, (2018).
- Frederico Valtuille Faleiro, André Nemésio and Rafael Loyola, Climate change likely to reduce orchid bee abundance even in climatic suitable sites, Global Change Biology, 24, 6, (2272-2283), (2018).
- Diana Stralberg, Carlos Carroll, John H. Pedlar, Chad B. Wilsey, Daniel W. McKenney, Scott E. Nielsen and Marie‐Josée Fortin, Macrorefugia for North American trees and songbirds: Climatic limiting factors and multi‐scale topographic influences, Global Ecology and Biogeography, 27, 6, (690-703), (2018).
- Lisbeth Morrison, Alba Estrada and Regan Early, Species traits suggest European mammals facing the greatest climate change are also least able to colonize new locations, Diversity and Distributions, 24, 9, (1321-1332), (2018).
- Shuang Xing, Wenda Cheng, Akihiro Nakamura, Chin Cheung Tang, Shuyin Huang, Erica Odell, Eben Goodale, Uromi M Goodale and Timothy C Bonebrake, Elevational clines in morphological traits of subtropical and tropical butterfly assemblages, Biological Journal of the Linnean Society, 10.1093/biolinnean/blx159, 123, 3, (506-517), (2018).
- Falko T. Buschke, Luc Brendonck and Bram Vanschoenwinkel, The conservation status of African vertebrates is unrelated to environmental and spatial patterns in their geographic ranges, Biodiversity and Conservation, 10.1007/s10531-017-1449-y, 27, 3, (567-582), (2017).
- Alba Estrada, Ignacio Morales‐Castilla, Catarina Meireles, Paul Caplat and Regan Early, Equipped to cope with climate change: traits associated with range filling across European taxa, Ecography, 41, 5, (770-781), (2017).
- Meryl C. Mims, Emily E. Hartfield Kirk, David A. Lytle and Julian D. Olden, Traits-based approaches support the conservation relevance of landscape genetics, Conservation Genetics, 10.1007/s10592-017-1028-5, 19, 1, (17-26), (2017).
- William W. L. Cheung, Miranda C. Jones, Gabriel Reygondeau and Thomas L. Frölicher, Opportunities for climate‐risk reduction through effective fisheries management, Global Change Biology, 24, 11, (5149-5163), (2018).
- Nathalie Butt and Rachael Gallagher, Using species traits to guide conservation actions under climate change, Climatic Change, 10.1007/s10584-018-2294-z, 151, 2, (317-332), (2018).
- Miranda C. Jones and William W. L. Cheung, Using fuzzy logic to determine the vulnerability of marine species to climate change, Global Change Biology, 24, 2, (e719-e731), (2017).
- Anouschka R. Hof, Genoveva Rodríguez‐Castañeda, Andrew M. Allen, Roland Jansson and Christer Nilsson, Vulnerability of Subarctic and Arctic breeding birds, Ecological Applications, 27, 1, (219-234), (2017).
- Mathieu Floury, Philippe Usseglio‐Polatera, Cecile Delattre and Yves Souchon, Assessing long‐term effects of multiple, potentially confounded drivers in ecosystems from species traits, Global Change Biology, 23, 6, (2297-2307), (2017).
- Semra Yalcin, Shawn J. Leroux and Jonathan Belmaker, Diversity and suitability of existing methods and metrics for quantifying species range shifts, Global Ecology and Biogeography, 26, 6, (609-624), (2017).
- Cleber Juliano Neves Chaves, Bárbara Simões Santos Leal and José Pires de Lemos-Filho, How are endemic and widely distributed bromeliads responding to warming temperatures? A case study in a Brazilian hotspot, Flora, (2017).
- Raquel A. Garcia, Mar Cabeza, Res Altwegg and Miguel B. Araújo, Do projections from bioclimatic envelope models and climate change metrics match?, Global Ecology and Biogeography, 25, 1, (65-74), (2015).
- Nicola J. van Wilgen, Victoria Goodall, Stephen Holness, Steven L. Chown and Melodie A. McGeoch, Rising temperatures and changing rainfall patterns in South Africa's national parks, International Journal of Climatology, 36, 2, (706-721), (2015).
- Jonathan A. Hare, Wendy E. Morrison, Mark W. Nelson, Megan M. Stachura, Eric J. Teeters, Roger B. Griffis, Michael A. Alexander, James D. Scott, Larry Alade, Richard J. Bell, Antonie S. Chute, Kiersten L. Curti, Tobey H. Curtis, Daniel Kircheis, John F. Kocik, Sean M. Lucey, Camilla T. McCandless, Lisa M. Milke, David E. Richardson, Eric Robillard, Harvey J. Walsh, M. Conor McManus, Katrin E. Marancik, Carolyn A. Griswold and Jan Geert Hiddink, A Vulnerability Assessment of Fish and Invertebrates to Climate Change on the Northeast U.S. Continental Shelf, PLOS ONE, 11, 2, (e0146756), (2016).
- Damien A. Fordham, H. Resit Akçakaya, John Alroy, Frédérik Saltré, Tom M. L. Wigley and Barry W. Brook, Predicting and mitigating future biodiversity loss using long-term ecological proxies, Nature Climate Change, 10.1038/nclimate3086, 6, 10, (909-916), (2016).
- Leticia M. Ochoa-Ochoa, Oscar A. Flores-Villela and Juan E. Bezaury-Creel, Using one vs. many, sensitivity and uncertainty analyses of species distribution models with focus on conservation area networks, Ecological Modelling, 10.1016/j.ecolmodel.2015.10.031, 320, (372-382), (2016).
- Nicole Colin, Cinta Porte, Denise Fernandes, Carlos Barata, Francesc Padrós, Maite Carrassón, Mario Monroy, Oriol Cano-Rocabayera, Adolfo de Sostoa, Benjamín Piña and Alberto Maceda-Veiga, Ecological relevance of biomarkers in monitoring studies of macro-invertebrates and fish in Mediterranean rivers, Science of The Total Environment, 10.1016/j.scitotenv.2015.06.099, 540, (307-323), (2016).
- Alba Estrada, Ignacio Morales-Castilla, Paul Caplat and Regan Early, Usefulness of Species Traits in Predicting Range Shifts, Trends in Ecology & Evolution, 10.1016/j.tree.2015.12.014, 31, 3, (190-203), (2016).
- Christopher P. Nadeau and Angela K. Fuller, Combining landscape variables and species traits can improve the utility of climate change vulnerability assessments, Biological Conservation, 202, (30), (2016).
- Han Meng, Jamie Carr, Joe Beraducci, Phil Bowles, William R. Branch, Claudia Capitani, Jumapili Chenga, Neil Cox, Kim Howell, Patrick Malonza, Rob Marchant, Boniface Mbilinyi, Kusaga Mukama, Charles Msuya, Philip J. Platts, Ignas Safari, Stephen Spawls, Yara Shennan-Farpon, Philipp Wagner and Neil D. Burgess, Tanzania's reptile biodiversity: Distribution, threats and climate change vulnerability, Biological Conservation, 10.1016/j.biocon.2016.04.008, 204, (72-82), (2016).
- Carolina Madeira, Diana Madeira, Mário S. Diniz, Henrique N. Cabral and Catarina Vinagre, Thermal acclimation in clownfish: An integrated biomarker response and multi-tissue experimental approach, Ecological Indicators, 10.1016/j.ecolind.2016.07.009, 71, (280-292), (2016).
- Adriano Mazziotta, María Triviño, Olli-Pekka Tikkanen, Jari Kouki, Harri Strandman and Mikko Mönkkönen, Habitat associations drive species vulnerability to climate change in boreal forests, Climatic Change, 10.1007/s10584-015-1591-z, 135, 3-4, (585-595), (2016).
- Eric I. Ameca y Juárez and Zhigang Jiang, Flood exposure for vertebrates in China's terrestrial priority areas for biodiversity conservation: Identifying internal refugia, Biological Conservation, 10.1016/j.biocon.2016.04.021, 199, (137-145), (2016).
- Alba Estrada, Catarina Meireles, Ignacio Morales‐Castilla, Peter Poschlod, David Vieites, Miguel B. Araújo and Regan Early, Species' intrinsic traits inform their range limitations and vulnerability under environmental change, Global Ecology and Biogeography, 24, 7, (849-858), (2015).
- Daniel B. Segan, David G. Hole, Camila I. Donatti, Chris Zganjar, Shaun Martin, Stuart H. M. Butchart and James E. M. Watson, Considering the impact of climate change on human communities significantly alters the outcome of species and site‐based vulnerability assessments, Diversity and Distributions, 21, 9, (1101-1111), (2015).
- A. D. Mazaris, D. Vokou, V. Almpanidou, O. Türkozan and S. P. Sgardelis, Low conservatism of the climatic niche of sea turtles and implications for predicting future distributions, Ecosphere, 6, 9, (1-12), (2015).
- S.G. Willis, W. Foden, D.J. Baker, E. Belle, N.D. Burgess, J.A. Carr, N. Doswald, R.A. Garcia, A. Hartley, C. Hof, T. Newbold, C. Rahbek, R.J. Smith, P. Visconti, B.E. Young and S.H.M. Butchart, Integrating climate change vulnerability assessments from species distribution models and trait-based approaches, Biological Conservation, 10.1016/j.biocon.2015.05.001, 190, (167-178), (2015).
- A. Egizi, N. H. Fefferman and D. M. Fonseca, Evidence that implicit assumptions of 'no evolution' of disease vectors in changing environments can be violated on a rapid timescale, Philosophical Transactions of the Royal Society B: Biological Sciences, 370, 1665, (20140136), (2015).
- Shannon M. Still, Anne L. Frances, Amanda C. Treher and Leah Oliver, Using Two Climate Change Vulnerability Assessment Methods to Prioritize and Manage Rare Plants: A Case Study, Natural Areas Journal, 10.3375/043.035.0115, 35, 1, (106-121), (2015).
- María Piquer-Rodríguez, Sebastián Torella, Gregorio Gavier-Pizarro, José Volante, Daniel Somma, Rubén Ginzburg and Tobias Kuemmerle, Effects of past and future land conversions on forest connectivity in the Argentine Chaco, Landscape Ecology, 30, 5, (817), (2015).
- Miranda C. Jones and William W. L. Cheung, Multi-model ensemble projections of climate change effects on global marine biodiversity, ICES Journal of Marine Science, 72, 3, (741), (2015).
- D.E. Bowler, P. Haase, I. Kröncke, O. Tackenberg, H.G. Bauer, C. Brendel, R.W. Brooker, M. Gerisch, K. Henle, T. Hickler, C. Hof, S. Klotz, I. Kühn, S. Matesanz, R. O‘Hara, D. Russell, O. Schweiger, F. Valladares, E. Welk, M. Wiemers and K. Böhning-Gaese, A cross-taxon analysis of the impact of climate change on abundance trends in central Europe, Biological Conservation, 10.1016/j.biocon.2015.03.034, 187, (41-50), (2015).
- Philip J. Platts, Raquel A. Garcia, Christian Hof, Wendy Foden, Louis A. Hansen, Carsten Rahbek and Neil D. Burgess, Conservation implications of omitting narrow‐ranging taxa from species distribution models, now and in the future, Diversity and Distributions, 20, 11, (1307-1320), (2014).
- Xiao-Ning Wang, Hai-Yu Ding, Xu-Gang He, Yang Dai, Yuan Zhang and Sen Ding, Assessing Fish Species Tolerance in the Huntai River Basin, China: Biological Traits versus Weighted Averaging Approaches, Water, 10.3390/w10121843, 10, 12, (1843), (2018).
