Original article
Tablet use in schools: a critical review of the evidence for learning outcomes
Abstract
The increased popularity of tablets in general has led to uptake in education. We critically review the literature reporting use of tablets by primary and secondary school children across the curriculum, with a particular emphasis on learning outcomes. The systematic review methodology was used, and our literature search resulted in 33 relevant studies meeting the inclusion criteria. A total of 23 met the minimum quality criteria and were examined in detail (16 reporting positive learning outcomes, 5 no difference and 2 negative learning outcomes). Explanations underlying these observations were analysed, and factors contributing to successful uses of tablets are discussed. While we hypothesize how tablets can viably support children in completing a variety of learning tasks (across a range of contexts and academic subjects), the fragmented nature of the current knowledge base, and the scarcity of rigorous studies, makes it difficult to draw firm conclusions. The generalizability of evidence is limited, and detailed explanations as to how, or why, using tablets within certain activities can improve learning remain elusive. We recommend that future research moves beyond exploration towards systematic and in‐depth investigations building on the existing findings documented here.
Citing Literature
Number of times cited: 46
- Natalie Pareja Roblin, Jo Tondeur, Joke Voogt, Bram Bruggeman, Griet Mathieu and Johan van Braak, Practical considerations informing teachers’ technology integration decisions: the case of tablet PCs, Technology, Pedagogy and Education, (1), (2018).
- Emily C. Bouck, Christopher Working and Erin Bone, Manipulative Apps to Support Students With Disabilities in Mathematics, Intervention in School and Clinic, 53, 3, (177), (2018).
- Stefano Cacciamani, Daniela Villani, Andrea Bonanomi, Claudia Carissoli, Maria Giulia Olivari, Laura Morganti, Giuseppe Riva and Emanuela Confalonieri, Factors Affecting Students' Acceptance of Tablet PCs: A Study in Italian High Schools, Journal of Research on Technology in Education, 10.1080/15391523.2017.1409672, 50, 2, (120-133), (2018).
- C. Herodotou, Young children and tablets: A systematic review of effects on learning and development, Journal of Computer Assisted Learning, 34, 1, (1-9), (2017).
- Daniela Villani, Laura Morganti, Claudia Carissoli, Elena Gatti, Andrea Bonanomi, Stefano Cacciamani, Emanuela Confalonieri and Giuseppe Riva, Students' acceptance of tablet PCs in Italian high schools: Profiles and differences, British Journal of Educational Technology, 49, 3, (533-544), (2017).
- Diane Dalby and Malcolm Swan, Using digital technology to enhance formative assessment in mathematics classrooms, British Journal of Educational Technology, (2018).
- Sara Hennessy, Carina Girvan, Manolis Mavrikis, Sara Price and Niall Winters, Editorial, British Journal of Educational Technology, 49, 1, (3), (2018).
- Louis Major and Steven Watson, Using video to support in-service teacher professional development: the state of the field, limitations and possibilities, Technology, Pedagogy and Education, 27, 1, (49), (2018).
- Sarah K. Howard, Jie Yang, Jun Ma, Karl Maton and Ellie Rennie, App clusters: Exploring patterns of multiple app use in primary learning contexts, Computers & Education, 10.1016/j.compedu.2018.08.021, 127, (154-164), (2018).
- Ilja Cornelisz and Chris Klaveren, Student engagement with computerized practising: Ability, task value, and difficulty perceptions, Journal of Computer Assisted Learning, 34, 6, (828-842), (2018).
- Michael Reichert and Chrystalla Mouza, Teacher practices during Year 4 of a one‐to‐one mobile learning initiative, Journal of Computer Assisted Learning, 34, 6, (762-774), (2018).
- Guido Kempter, Patrick Jost and Andreas Künz, Gut zu wissen: Technologiegestütztes Lernen während der Arbeit, Zukunft der Arbeit – Perspektive Mensch, 10.1007/978-3-658-22099-0_14, (205-215), (2018).
- Valentina Morgana and Prithvi N Shrestha, Investigating Students' and Teachers' Perceptions of Using the iPad in an Italian English as a Foreign Language Classroom, International Journal of Computer-Assisted Language Learning and Teaching, 10.4018/IJCALLT.2018070102, 8, 3, (29-49), (2018).
- Lauren Eutsler, 1:1 iPads in 1st Grade: Case Study of a Teacher’s Concerns and Implementation, Handbook of Mobile Teaching and Learning, 10.1007/978-3-642-41981-2_132-1, (1-16), (2018).
- Daniel Churchill, Mobile Technologies and Digital Resources for Learning, Digital Resources for Learning, 10.1007/978-981-10-3776-4_9, (175-226), (2017).
- Louis Major, Bjoern Haßler and Sara Hennessy, Tablet Use in Schools: Impact, Affordances and Considerations, Handbook on Digital Learning for K-12 Schools, 10.1007/978-3-319-33808-8_8, (115-128), (2016).
- Monther M. Elaish, Liyana Shuib, Norjihan Abdul Ghani, Elaheh Yadegaridehkordi and Musaab Alaa, Mobile Learning for English Language Acquisition: Taxonomy, Challenges, and Recommendations, IEEE Access, 5, (19033), (2017).
- Elena Savina, Jennifer L. Mills, Kelly Atwood and Jason Cha, Digital Media and Youth: a Primer for School Psychologists, Contemporary School Psychology, 21, 1, (80), (2017).
- Laura A. Outhwaite, Anthea Gulliford and Nicola J. Pitchford, Closing the gap: Efficacy of a tablet intervention to support the development of early mathematical skills in UK primary school children, Computers & Education, 108, (43), (2017).
- Neil Selwyn, Selena Nemorin, Scott Bulfin and Nicola F. Johnson, Left to their own devices: the everyday realities of one-to-one classrooms, Oxford Review of Education, 43, 3, (289), (2017).
- Jasmin Bastian, Tablets zur Neubestimmung des Lernens?, Tablets in Schule und Unterricht, 10.1007/978-3-658-13809-7_7, (139-173), (2016).
- Doreen Prasse, Nives Egger and Beat Döbeli Honegger, Mobiles Lernen. Auch zu Hause?, Tablets in Schule und Unterricht, 10.1007/978-3-658-13809-7_10, (209-239), (2016).
- Emily C. Bouck, Laura Bassette, Jordan Shurr, Jiyoon Park, Jackie Kerr and Abbie Whorley, Teaching Equivalent Fractions to Secondary Students With Disabilities via the Virtual–Representational–Abstract Instructional Sequence, Journal of Special Education Technology, 32, 4, (220), (2017).
- Omar Sulaymani and Marilyn Fleer, Perezhivanie as a phenomenon and a unit of analysis for studying children’s interactions with iPads in the early years of school in Saudi Arabia, Early Child Development and Care, (1), (2017).
- Bogi Perelmutter, Karla K. McGregor and Katherine R. Gordon, Assistive technology interventions for adolescents and adults with learning disabilities: An evidence-based systematic review and meta-analysis, Computers & Education, 114, (139), (2017).
- Gabrielle Leroux, Jean-Marc Monteil and Pascal Huguet, Apprentissages scolaires et technologies numériques : Une revue critique des méta-analyses, L’Année psychologique, (1), (2017).
- H. Montrieux, A. Raes and T. Schellens, ‘The best app is the teacher’ Introducing classroom scripts in technology‐enhanced education, Journal of Computer Assisted Learning, 33, 3, (267-281), (2017).
- Marina Volk, Mara Cotič, Matej Zajc and Andreja Istenic Starcic, Tablet-based cross-curricular maths vs. traditional maths classroom practice for higher-order learning outcomes, Computers & Education, 114, (1), (2017).
- Kerstin Drossel and Birgit Eickelmann, The Use of Tablets in Secondary Schools and Its Relationship with Computer Literacy, Tomorrow's Learning: Involving Everyone. Learning with and about Technologies and Computing, 10.1007/978-3-319-74310-3_14, (114-124), (2018).
- Anne Burke and Janette Hughes, A shifting landscape: using tablets to support learning in students with diverse abilities, Technology, Pedagogy and Education, (1), (2017).
- Stefan Aufenanger, Zum Stand der Forschung zum Tableteinsatz in Schule und Unterricht aus nationaler und internationaler Sicht, Tablets in Schule und Unterricht, 10.1007/978-3-658-13809-7_6, (119-138), (2016).
- Claudia Nerdel, Medien im naturwissenschaftlichen Unterricht, Grundlagen der Naturwissenschaftsdidaktik, 10.1007/978-3-662-53158-7_10, (189-212), (2017). 2017 IEEE 25th International Requirements Engineering Conference Workshops (REW) Lisbon, Portugal 2017 IEEE 25th International Requirements Engineering Conference Workshops (REW) IEEE , (2017). 978-1-5386-3488-2 Alexis Rougnant, Mirko Gelsomini and Franca Garzotto WAYZ: A Co-designed Touch-Ready Game for Children with Special Needs to Assess and Improve Visual Perception Skills , (2017). 160 163 8054846 , 10.1109/REW.2017.40 http://ieeexplore.ieee.org/document/8054846/
- Hye Jeong Kim and Hyeoncheol Kim, Investigating Teachers’ Pedagogical Experiences with Tablet Integration in Korean Rural Schools, The Asia-Pacific Education Researcher, 26, 1-2, (107), (2017).
- Gabrielle Leroux, Jean-Marc Monteil and Pascal Huguet, Apprentissages scolaires et technologies numériques : Une revue critique des méta-analyses, L’Année psychologique, 117, 04, (433), (2017).
- Kristine Kwok, Siba Ghrear, Vivian Li, Taeh Haddock, Patrick Coleman and Susan A. J. Birch, Children Can Learn New Facts Equally Well From Interactive Media Versus Face to Face Instruction, Frontiers in Psychology, 07, (2016).
- Claire Hamshire and Julie Lachkovic, Developing a Framework for App Evaluation: Empowering Learning and Communication with iPads for Children and Young People with Communication Impairments, Building Sustainable Health Ecosystems, 10.1007/978-3-319-44672-1_7, (69-81), (2016).
- Petra A. Arndt, Computer usage for learning how to read and write in primary school, Trends in Neuroscience and Education, 5, 3, (90), (2016).
- Paula J. Hubber, Laura A. Outhwaite, Antonie Chigeda, Simon McGrath, Jeremy Hodgen and Nicola J. Pitchford, Should Touch Screen Tablets Be Used to Improve Educational Outcomes in Primary School Children in Developing Countries?, Frontiers in Psychology, 7, (2016).
- Cristóbal Suárez-Guerrero, Carmen Lloret-Catalá and Santiago Mengual-Andrés, Teachers' Perceptions of the Digital Transformation of the Classroom through the Use of Tablets: A Study in Spain, Comunicar, 10.3916/C49-2016-08, 24, 49, (81-89), (2016).
- Symeon Retalis, Fotini Paraskeva, Aikaterini Alexiou, Zoi Litou and Theofili Sbrini, Leveraging the 1:1 iPad approach for enhanced learning in the classroom, Educational Media International, 10.1080/09523987.2018.1512463, (1-18), (2018).
- Francisco Ballesta Pagán, Josefina Lozano Martínez and Mari Cerezo Máiquez, Internet Use by Secondary School Students: A Digital Divide in Sustainable Societies?, Sustainability, 10.3390/su10103703, 10, 10, (3703), (2018).
- Keith Turvey, Humanising as innovation in a cold climate of [so-called-evidence-based] teacher education, Journal of Education for Teaching, 10.1080/02607476.2019.1550603, (1-16), (2018).
- Heping Xie, Ji Peng, Mengyuan Qin, Xuzhe Huang, Fei Tian and Zongkui Zhou, Can Touchscreen Devices be Used to Facilitate Young Children's Learning? A Meta-Analysis of Touchscreen Learning Effect, Frontiers in Psychology, 10.3389/fpsyg.2018.02580, 9, (2018).
- Cristina SÁNCHEZ-MARTÍNEZ, María-Carmen RICOY and Tiberio FELIZ-MURIAS, Actividades y dinámicas implementadas con la tableta en un centro de educación básica de España, Educação e Pesquisa, 10.1590/s1678-4634201844183309, 44, 0, (2018).
- Emmanuel Fokides and Aikaterini Mastrokoukou, Results from a Study for Teaching Human Body Systems to Primary School Students Using Tablets, Contemporary Educational Technology, 10.30935/cet.414808, (154-170), (2018).
