Article
Public Perceptions of the Legitimacy of the Law and Legal Authorities: Evidence from the Caribbean
Funding for this research was provided by the Ministry of National Security (MNS) of Trinidad and Tobago. The views expressed in this article are those of the authors alone and do not represent the official policies or positions of the MNS or the Trinidad and Tobago Police Service. This research was approved by the Institutional Review Boards at George Mason University and American University. We thank the editors and the anonymous reviewers for their comments on a previous draft.
Get access to the full version of this article.View access options below.
Log in with Open Athens, Shibboleth, or your institutional credentials.
If you have previously obtained access with your personal account, Please log in.
If you previously purchased this article, Log in to Readcube.
You previously purchased this article on READCUBE_PURCHASE_DATE. Click on an option below to access.
Logged in as READCUBE_USER. Log out of ReadCube.
Abstract
Research on procedural justice and legitimacy has expanded greatly across the social sciences in recent years. The process‐based model of regulation, which links people's assessments of procedural justice and legitimacy to their compliance with the law and legal authorities, has become particularly influential in criminology and sociolegal studies. A review of the previous research on perceived legitimacy highlights two important features. First, legitimacy has been conceptualized and measured in many different ways. Second, most of the research on legitimacy has focused on only a handful of developed nations. Using survey data from Trinidad and Tobago, this article examines the conceptualization and measurement of the perceived legitimacy of the law and legal authorities. The findings indicate that some of the prominent conceptual and measurement models used in previous research are not empirically valid in the Trinidadian context. The implications of the results for conceptualization, theory, and future research are discussed.
Citing Literature
Number of times cited according to CrossRef: 43
- P. Colin Bolger and Glenn D. Walters, The relationship between police procedural justice, police legitimacy, and people's willingness to cooperate with law enforcement: A meta-analysis, Journal of Criminal Justice, 10.1016/j.jcrimjus.2019.01.001, 60, (93-99), (2019).
- Richard K. Moule, George W. Burruss, Megan M. Parry and Bryanna Fox, Assessing the Direct and Indirect Effects of Legitimacy on Public Empowerment of Police: A Study of Public Support for Police Militarization in America, Law & Society Review, 53, 1, (77-107), (2018).
- Justice Tankebe, In their own eyes: an empirical examination of police self-legitimacy, International Journal of Comparative and Applied Criminal Justice, 10.1080/01924036.2018.1487870, 43, 2, (99-116), (2018).
- Daniel K. Pryce, The Relative Effects of Normative and Instrumental Models of Policing on Police Empowerment: Evidence From a Sample of Sub-Saharan African Immigrants, Criminal Justice Policy Review, 10.1177/0887403416675019, 30, 3, (428-450), (2016).
- Francis D. Boateng and Jihye Yoo Lee, Apartheid and post-apartheid analysis of public confidence in the police, Policing: An International Journal, 10.1108/PIJPSM-06-2017-0074, 41, 6, (766-781), (2018).
- Lidia E. Nuño, Hispanics’ perceived procedural justice, legitimacy, and willingness to cooperate with the police, Police Practice and Research, 19, 2, (153), (2018).
- Edward Maguire, Maya Barak, William Wells and Charles Katz, Attitudes towards the Use of Violence against Police among Occupy Wall Street Protesters, Policing: A Journal of Policy and Practice, (2018).
- Edward R. Maguire, New frontiers in research on procedural justice and legitimacy in policing, Police Practice and Research, 19, 2, (107), (2018).
- Hilke A. M. Grootelaar and Kees van den Bos, How Litigants in Dutch Courtrooms Come to Trust Judges: The Role of Perceived Procedural Justice, Outcome Favorability, and Other Sociolegal Moderators, Law & Society Review, 52, 1, (234-268), (2018).
- Oluwagbenga Michael Akinlabi and Kristina Murphy, Dull compulsion or perceived legitimacy? Assessing why people comply with the law in Nigeria, Police Practice and Research, 19, 2, (186), (2018).
- Youngki Woo, Edward R. Maguire and Jacinta M. Gau, Direct and indirect effects of procedural justice on cooperation and compliance: evidence from South Korea, Police Practice and Research, 19, 2, (168), (2018).
- Valerie Jenness and Kitty Calavita, “It Depends on the Outcome”: Prisoners, Grievances, and Perceptions of Justice, Law & Society Review, 52, 1, (41-72), (2018).
- David H. Tyler, Maya Barak, Edward R. Maguire and William Wells, The effects of procedural injustice on the use of violence against police by Occupy Wall Street protesters, Police Practice and Research, 19, 2, (138), (2018).
- Emily Owens, David Weisburd, Karen L. Amendola and Geoffrey P. Alpert, Can You Build a Better Cop?, Criminology & Public Policy, 17, 1, (41-87), (2018).
- Brandy L. Blasko and Faye S. Taxman, Are Supervision Practices Procedurally Fair? Development and Predictive Utility of a Procedural Justice Measure for Use in Community Corrections Settings, Criminal Justice and Behavior, 45, 3, (402), (2018).
- Daniel K. Pryce, Does procedural justice influence general satisfaction with police? A study from a hard-to-reach population of immigrants in the United States, Journal of Crime and Justice, 41, 1, (31), (2018).
- William D. Moreto and Jacinta M. Gau, Deterrence, Legitimacy, and Wildlife Crime in Protected Areas, Conservation Criminology, (45-58), (2017).
- Edward R. Maguire, Todd Armstrong and Devon Johnson, The Structure of Citizen Perceptions of Crime and Disorder: New Insights from a Caribbean Community, Journal of Quantitative Criminology, 33, 4, (675), (2017).
- Edward R. Maguire, Belén V. Lowrey and Devon Johnson, Evaluating the relative impact of positive and negative encounters with police: a randomized experiment, Journal of Experimental Criminology, 13, 3, (367), (2017).
- J. A. Hamm, R. Trinkner and J. D. Carr, Fair Process, Trust, and Cooperation: Moving Toward an Integrated Framework of Police Legitimacy, Criminal Justice and Behavior, 44, 9, (1183), (2017).
- Jingkang Gao and Jinhua Zhao, Normative and image motivations for transportation policy compliance, Urban Studies, 54, 14, (3318), (2017).
- Edward R. Maguire, Devon Johnson, Joseph B. Kuhns and Robert Apostolos, The effects of community policing on fear of crime and perceived safety: findings from a pilot project in Trinidad and Tobago, Policing and Society, (1), (2017).
- Daniel K. Pryce, Devon Johnson and Edward R. Maguire, Procedural Justice, Obligation to Obey, and Cooperation with Police in a Sample of Ghanaian Immigrants, Criminal Justice and Behavior, 44, 5, (733), (2017).
- Jonathan Jackson, Jenna Milani and Ben Bradford, Empirical Legitimacy and Normative Compliance with the Law, Global Encyclopedia of Public Administration, Public Policy, and Governance, 10.1007/978-3-319-31816-5_1914-1, (1-8), (2017).
- Belén V. Lowrey‐Kinberg and Grace Sullivan Buker, “I'm Giving You a Lawful Order”: Dialogic Legitimacy in Sandra Bland's Traffic Stop, Law & Society Review, 51, 2, (379-412), (2017).
- Emily Ryo, Legal Attitudes of Immigrant Detainees, Law & Society Review, 51, 1, (99-131), (2017).
- Jonathan Jackson and Jouni Kuha, How Theory Guides Measurement, The Handbook of Measurement Issues in Criminology and Criminal Justice, (377-415), (2016).
- Justice Tankebe and Muhammad Asif, Police legitimacy and support for vigilante violence in Pakistan, International Journal of Comparative and Applied Criminal Justice, 40, 4, (343), (2016).
- Scott E. Wolfe, Justin Nix, Robert Kaminski and Jeff Rojek, Is the Effect of Procedural Justice on Police Legitimacy Invariant? Testing the Generality of Procedural Justice and Competing Antecedents of Legitimacy, Journal of Quantitative Criminology, 32, 2, (253), (2016).
- Ian Brunton-Smith and Daniel J. McCarthy, Prison Legitimacy and Procedural Fairness: A Multilevel Examination of Prisoners in England and Wales, Justice Quarterly, 33, 6, (1029), (2016).
- Anna Efverström, Nader Ahmadi, David Hoff and Åsa Bäckström, Anti-doping and legitimacy: an international survey of elite athletes’ perceptions, International Journal of Sport Policy and Politics, 8, 3, (491), (2016).
- Daniel K. Pryce, Ghanaian Immigrants’ Experiences With and Perceptions of U.S. Police, Criminal Justice Review, 41, 4, (469), (2016).
- Belén V. Lowrey, Edward R. Maguire and Richard R. Bennett, Testing the Effects of Procedural Justice and Overaccommodation in Traffic Stops, Criminal Justice and Behavior, 43, 10, (1430), (2016).
- Edward R. Maguire, Maya Barak, Karie Cross and Kris Lugo, Attitudes among Occupy DC participants about the use of violence against police, Policing and Society, (1), (2016).
- Aziz Z. Huq, Jonathan Jackson and Rick Trinkner, Legitimating Practices: Revisiting the Predicates of Police Legitimacy, British Journal of Criminology, (azw037), (2016).
- Alysia Blackham, Legitimacy and empirical evidence in the UK courts, Griffith Law Review, 25, 3, (414), (2016).
- Mahfuzul I. Khondaker, Yuning Wu and Eric G. Lambert, The views of Bangladeshi immigrants on the police in New York City, Journal of Crime and Justice, 39, 4, (528), (2016).
- Stephen D. Mastrofski, Tal Jonathan-Zamir, Shomron Moyal and James J. Willis, Predicting Procedural Justice in Police–Citizen Encounters, Criminal Justice and Behavior, 43, 1, (119), (2016).
- Gail Super, Volatile Sovereignty: Governing Crime through the Community in Khayelitsha, Law & Society Review, 50, 2, (450-483), (2016).
- Jacinta M. Gau and Rod K. Brunson, Procedural Injustice, Lost Legitimacy, and Self-Help, Journal of Contemporary Criminal Justice, 31, 2, (132), (2015).
- Stanislaw Burdziej, Keith Guzik and Bartosz Pilitowski, Fairness at Trial: The Impact of Procedural Justice and Other Experiential Factors on Criminal Defendants' Perceptions of Court Legitimacy in Poland, Law & Social Inquiry, , (2018).
- Daniel K Pryce, George Wilson and Kenethia Fuller, Predictors of satisfaction with Kenya’s police and Kenya’s criminal justice system: Results from a sample of Kenyan college students, The Police Journal: Theory, Practice and Principles, 10.1177/0032258X18814281, (0032258X1881428), (2018).
- Nikolaos Stamatakis, Perceptions of Incarcerated Youth About Police Violence and Legitimacy in Trinidad and Tobago, Journal of Police and Criminal Psychology, 10.1007/s11896-018-9309-6, (2019).
